Fourth Circuit Upholds Dismissal of PPE Contract Suits
A foreign-citizen member of a plaintiff LLC destroyed diversity jurisdiction, the appeals court held.
Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Law

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit affirmed the dismissal of two contract actions for lack of subject matter jurisdiction. The plaintiff, a Texas-based medical supplies firm that had supplied personal protective equipment to Tanner Pharma UK Ltd. and TannerGAP Inc. during the COVID-19 pandemic, had asserted diversity jurisdiction before disclosing that one of its members was a Chinese citizen.
Why it matters
The ruling holds that an LLC takes the citizenship of each of its members, so a foreign member can defeat diversity jurisdiction even when the defendants are foreign. Courts must weigh both domestic and foreign citizenship of a dual-citizen LLC, and a later transfer of the foreign member's interest did not cure the defect.
The Fourth Circuit held that under 28 U.S.C. § 1332(a)(3), the LLC's Chinese member counted toward its citizenship, making the suit a foreign plaintiff against domestic and foreign defendants. The court declined to apply North Carolina's savings statute to permit refiling within one year, and it is not yet known whether the plaintiff will pursue further review.
The players
Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals
The federal appellate court covering Maryland, North Carolina, South Carolina, Virginia and West Virginia, which issued the ruling affirming dismissal.
Tanner Pharma UK Limited
A United Kingdom pharmaceutical company that was a counterparty to the personal protective equipment contract at issue.
TannerGAP, Inc.
A company that was a counterparty to the personal protective equipment contract at issue in the dismissed suits.
The details
The plaintiff LLC sued in federal court asserting diversity jurisdiction, and only during the litigation did it disclose that one of its members was a Chinese citizen. The district court dismissed the cases, and the Fourth Circuit affirmed, rejecting the argument that only the LLC's U.S. citizenship mattered and finding that a post-filing transfer of the foreign member's ownership interest did not cure the jurisdictional defect.
Timeline
COVID-19 pandemic: personal protective equipment contracts were executed.
At filing: the plaintiff asserted diversity jurisdiction.
During litigation: the Chinese citizen member was disclosed.
November 15, 2026: the Fourth Circuit affirmed dismissal of both actions.
Legal Context
The decision applies 28 U.S.C. § 1332(a)(3) to an LLC whose citizenship includes a foreign member, extending the statute's alienage rules to a plaintiff's own foreign ties rather than only to foreign defendants. It places the ruling within the long line of federal decisions requiring courts to trace the citizenship of every member of an unincorporated entity.
Businesses with foreign members that sue in federal court on diversity grounds should confirm the citizenship of every member before filing, since one foreign member can defeat jurisdiction. Parties who file in the wrong forum may lose claims that a savings statute will not revive.
The takeaway
Citizenship of every member counts when an LLC sues in federal court, so jurisdictional checks should be completed before filing rather than after discovery. Early diligence on member ownership can prevent the loss of a case on procedural grounds.
Further reading
Explore more on the Law section for related federal court rulings and jurisdictional decisions.
Source note: This article includes information reported by North Carolina Lawyers Weekly.






