Multistate Brief Backs Florida Academic Speech Law
Alabama and 12 other states urge the U.S. Supreme Court to uphold Florida's law limiting how public university professors teach certain race- and sex-based concepts.
Updated on Nov. 10, 2026 in Law

Live Poll
Should public university professors be restricted in how they teach race and sex concepts?
Alabama Attorney General Steve Marshall joined a 13-state brief, led by Kentucky and Alabama, asking the U.S. Supreme Court to uphold Florida's Individual Freedom Act. The law restricts how public university professors may teach listed race- and sex-based concepts, and the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled in July that it likely violates professors' First Amendment rights.
Why it matters
The case will test whether public university professors have First Amendment protection for academic speech in the classroom or are treated like other public employees whose official speech the government may control. The outcome could shape how similar laws, including Alabama's, are handled on appeal.
The brief was filed by 13 states, with Kentucky and Alabama leading and Arkansas, Georgia, Idaho, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Louisiana, Montana, Nebraska, South Carolina and Texas joining. The Supreme Court has not yet acted on Florida's request to review the 11th Circuit's decision.
The players
Steve Marshall
Steve Marshall is the Attorney General of Alabama, the state's chief legal officer, who has led numerous multistate legal actions on conservative policy issues.
Florida Board of Governors
The Florida Board of Governors oversees the State University System of Florida and is the named petitioner seeking Supreme Court review of the appellate ruling against the state's academic speech law.
The details
Florida asked the Supreme Court to review the 11th Circuit's July decision in Florida Board of Governors v. Pernell. The Florida law bars professors from requiring students to believe listed concepts, while allowing them to discuss those concepts as part of instruction. A group of public university professors challenged the law on First Amendment grounds. The brief argues that professors lack a First Amendment right to control official speech made on the government's behalf and that academic freedom should not give professors special rights at the expense of students and universities.
Timeline
July 2026: The 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that Florida's law likely violates professors' First Amendment right to academic freedom.
November 10, 2026: Alabama Attorney General Steve Marshall joined the 13-state brief asking the Supreme Court to uphold the law.
Legal Context
The brief defends Florida's Individual Freedom Act, a state law that limits how public university professors may teach listed race- and sex-based concepts, against a July 2026 ruling by the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. Alabama's similar law is also being challenged and is on appeal before the same circuit.
Public university professors and students in Florida and Alabama face different rules on how certain race- and sex-based concepts may be taught, depending on how the courts resolve these challenges. Professors may still discuss listed concepts as part of instruction under Florida's law, but may not promote them or require students to believe them.
The takeaway
The Supreme Court's handling of Florida's petition could determine whether academic freedom protections for public university professors extend to classroom instruction in states with similar laws. Readers can track the case as filings and any review decision move forward.
Further reading
For more on how courts weigh government limits on classroom speech, explore Law coverage.
Live Poll
Should public university professors be restricted in how they teach race and sex concepts?






