Supreme Court Rejects Gays Against Groomers Appeal
The justices declined without explanation to hear activists' First Amendment claim against Colorado lawmakers who cut off their testimony.
Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Criminal Justice

Live Poll
Should lawmakers be allowed to cut off citizens who criticize proposed bills?
The U.S. Supreme Court on November 16 denied an appeal from Gays Against Groomers, a nonprofit, in its lawsuit alleging Colorado lawmakers violated the activists' First Amendment rights. No justices explained the decision, and at least four of nine justices must agree to accept a petition to hear a case.
Why it matters
The lawsuit arose after activists were cut off while testifying against a Colorado bill allowing convicts' name changes to match gender identity, and lower courts ruled legislators have immunity from such claims. The denial leaves that immunity ruling intact nationwide for the time being.
The Supreme Court declined to review the case, ending the activists' federal appeal. The Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals had upheld a 2024 federal ruling granting legislators immunity, and the Colorado proposal was later approved and enacted.
The players
Gays Against Groomers
A nonprofit organization that opposed the Colorado name-change bill and brought the First Amendment lawsuit against state lawmakers.
U.S. Supreme Court
The nation's highest court, which decides which cases it will hear and declined to take up this appeal.
The details
The activists said lawmakers cut them off during testimony because they misgendered a male convict who now identifies as female. The lawsuit sought a court injunction against future instances of such censorship, but the federal courts rejected the claims on immunity grounds.
Timeline
2024: A federal judge ruled state legislators enjoy immunity against such claims.
November 16, 2026: The Supreme Court denied the activists' appeal.
Legal Context
The denial leaves in place a lower-court ruling that state legislators are immune from First Amendment suits over how they conduct hearings. The case reflects a broader debate over how lawmakers handle contested testimony on gender identity.
The ruling means individuals who testify before state legislatures have limited federal recourse if lawmakers cut them off. Residents who attend public hearings may face the same restrictions in practice.
The takeaway
Public testimony rules in state legislatures can be limited without federal court remedy under current immunity precedent. Anyone planning to testify should review the hearing rules of the relevant chamber in advance.
Further reading
For related coverage, see Criminal Justice reporting on court rulings and legal challenges.
Live Poll
Should lawmakers be allowed to cut off citizens who criticize proposed bills?






