Ontario Court Orders New Trial in Police Damages Case

The Court of Appeal set aside a jury's malicious prosecution damages award against the Durham Regional Police Services Board.

Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Criminal Justice

Ontario Court Orders New Trial in Police Damages Case

Live Poll

Do you trust local courts to fairly handle complaints against police?

The Ontario Court of Appeal set aside a jury verdict on malicious prosecution damages in a civil suit brought by Sanayhie against the Durham Regional Police Services Board and two Durham Region police officers, and ordered a new trial. The appeal court found the trial judge's jury instructions did not track the wording of the verdict sheet.

Why it matters

The ruling sends the malicious prosecution claim back for retrial, leaving the damages question unresolved. It also underscores how precisely jury instructions must align with verdict forms in civil cases involving police conduct in Ontario.

The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, setting aside the trial judgment on malicious prosecution, punitive damages and costs, and ordered a new trial. The new trial's timing and outcome have not been reported.

The players

Durham Regional Police Services Board

The civic body responsible for governing the Durham Regional Police Service, which was named as a defendant in the civil action.

The details

The action arose from a December 22, 2015 incident in which Sanayhie was arrested after failing to leave an establishment in the early hours, and alleged wrongful arrest, excessive force and malicious prosecution. A January 2025 jury trial produced a verdict that appeared inconsistent with the trial judge's instructions, which the appeal court found did not track the verdict sheet's questions.

Timeline

  1. December 22, 2015: Early-hours incident leading to Sanayhie's arrest.

  2. January 2025: Jury trial and initial verdict in the action.

Legal Context

The decision reflects how Ontario appellate courts scrutinize the alignment between jury instructions and verdict forms in civil claims against police. Such rulings shape how malicious prosecution and excessive force claims are tried against police services across the province.

Residents in the Durham Region and across Ontario who have faced police encounters may watch this case as a reference point for how civil claims against officers are decided. The new trial means the malicious prosecution question remains open for now.

The takeaway

Civil claims against police can hinge on technical details such as how jury questions are worded, so outcomes may be revisited on appeal. Anyone following the case should expect the malicious prosecution damages question to be decided at a new trial.

Further reading

Explore more coverage of Criminal Justice rulings and legal proceedings affecting Ontario residents.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Law Times.

Live Poll

Do you trust local courts to fairly handle complaints against police?