Court Orders Review of Some Rejected Ontario Applications

Ontario Superior Court of Justice rules about 300 nominee applicants deserve individual review after roughly 2,600 were returned.

Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Immigration

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a stone government building with a tall colonnade against a flat horizon, evoking formal institutional review.
Ontario's Superior Court ruled Tuesday that about 300 foreign worker nominee applications returned without decision deserve individual review, after roughly 2,600 were set aside in late 2025. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you think governments should be able to change immigration rules after applications are filed?

The Ontario Superior Court of Justice ruled that approximately 300 foreign workers who applied for permanent residency through the Ontario Immigrant Nominee Program deserve individual review of their applications. The province had returned about 2,600 applications without a decision in late 2025.

Why it matters

The ruling addresses how Ontario handles nominee applications that were set aside under a regulation passed in June 2025, which allows returns without a decision over systemic fraud concerns. The Ontario Immigrant Nominee Program nominates candidates for permanent residence, while the Government of Canada makes the final decision.

Two of three Ontario Superior Court of Justice judges ruled that about 300 applicants deserved their applications considered, while a third judge dissented. The court order applies to the applicants before it, and it is not stated whether the remaining roughly 2,300 returned applications will be reviewed.

The players

Ontario Ministry of Labour

The Ontario ministry that returned the nominee applications and is the respondent in the court challenge, overseeing the province's immigrant nominee program.

The details

The Ministry of Labour returned approximately 2,600 applications without a decision under a regulation passed in June 2025, citing concerns about fraudulent activity and systemic misrepresentation. The court ruled that the Director had an obligation to decide whether to grant complete applications, and the applicants had asked for their files to be remitted under the process in place before the regulatory change.

Timeline

  1. June 2025: The Ministry passed a regulation permitting applications to be returned without a decision.

  2. Late 2025: Roughly 2,600 applicants were told their applications were rejected or returned.

  3. November 16, 2026: The Ontario Superior Court of Justice ruled in favour of approximately 300 applicants.

Political Context

The ruling is a court challenge to the June 2025 Ontario regulation that allowed nominee applications to be returned without a decision over systemic fraud concerns. Two judges found the applicants were entitled to individual consideration, while a third judge dissented, leaving the scope of the regulation's application contested.

Applicants whose nominee applications were returned without a decision may have their files reconsidered under the court order, but only for the applicants before the court. Other affected applicants should watch for how the Ministry responds to the ruling.

The takeaway

Individual nominee applicants can rely on court-ordered review only where a ruling names them, so those affected should track their own files closely. The case shows that provincial fraud rules can be tested in court when applications are set aside without a decision.

Further reading

Explore more Immigration coverage to see how provincial nominee programs fit into Canada's wider permanent residency system.

Source note: This article includes information reported by CityNews Toronto.

Live Poll

Do you think governments should be able to change immigration rules after applications are filed?