Court Certifies COVID-19 Class Action Against Huron Lodge
Ontario's Superior Court has allowed a class action over COVID-19 outbreak claims at the long-term care home to proceed.
Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in COVID-19

The Superior Court of Justice certified a COVID-19 class action against Huron Lodge, a long-term care home. The court ruled that plaintiffs asserted a reasonable cause of action in gross negligence.
Why it matters
The ruling allows residents, visitors and family members to pursue shared claims against the facility collectively, rather than through separate lawsuits. It also applies a gross negligence theory that the court recognized in the earlier Pugliese v. Chartwell decision for COVID-related cases against long-term care homes.
The court's certification ruling sets out proposed classes of Residents, Visitors and Family Law Act claimants, and found the claims shared factual and legal similarities. Whether the allegations of chronic deficiencies at Huron Lodge can be proven remains to be determined.
The players
Huron Lodge
A long-term care home in Ontario that is the defendant in the COVID-19 class action certified by the Superior Court.
Chartwell
A Canadian operator of long-term care homes whose related COVID-19 case, Pugliese v. Chartwell, shaped the gross negligence principles applied here.
The details
The court identified common issues including outdated, physically neglected and overcrowded facilities, inadequate infection prevention and control training and protocols, systematic failures to inspect and oversee compliance, and understaffing. The court found some factual basis for plaintiffs' allegation that Huron Lodge was ripe for outbreaks due to chronic, long-standing deficiencies.
Timeline
2024: Pugliese v. Chartwell, 2024 ONSC 1135 recognized the gross negligence cause of action for COVID-related cases against long-term care homes.
June 5: The Superior Court preferred the more flexibly defined period proposed by the plaintiff for the infection prevention and control claim concerning Huron Lodge.
Health Landscape
The ruling follows Pugliese v. Chartwell, 2024 ONSC 1135, which recognized a gross negligence cause of action for COVID-related claims against long-term care homes. It extends that precedent by allowing a class action against an individual facility to move forward on the same theory.
Residents and families of long-term care homes may be able to join collective claims if they were affected by COVID-19 outbreaks linked to facility conditions. The certification means those eligible will need to watch for notices about class membership as the case proceeds.
The takeaway
Collective actions like this one allow many people affected by the same facility's conditions to pursue claims together. Residents and families affected by long-term care outbreaks should keep records and be alert to any class notices.
Further reading
For more on pandemic-era care standards, see the COVID-19 section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Law Times.










