Court Quashes B.C. Approval of KSM Mine

The B.C. Supreme Court found the Province failed to properly consult the Tsetsaut Skii km Lax Ha Nation before granting a Substantial Start Determination for the project.

Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Law

Court Quashes B.C. Approval of KSM Mine

B.C. Supreme Court Justice Emily Burke quashed the Province's Substantial Start Determination for Seabridge Gold's KSM mine, confirming the Province failed to properly consult the Tsetsaut Skii km Lax Ha Nation. The court ruled the Province must engage in deep consultation with the Nation, but did not rule on whether the determination was unreasonable.

Why it matters

The decision requires the Province to carry out deep consultation with the Nation before the project can move forward under the approval it granted. For investors and residents of northwestern British Columbia, the ruling adds legal uncertainty to a major mining development.

The B.C. Supreme Court has quashed the Substantial Start Determination granted in July 2024, with the Province required to undertake deep consultation with the Tsetsaut Skii km Lax Ha Nation. The court has not addressed whether the determination itself was unreasonable.

The players

Seabridge Gold Inc.

A publicly traded mining company whose KSM project in northwestern British Columbia is the subject of the court decision.

Province of British Columbia

The provincial government whose Substantial Start Determination for the KSM mine was quashed by the court.

The details

Justice Emily Burke confirmed key elements of a June ruling in favour of the Nation, finding the Province did not properly consult before granting the determination. The Gitxsan Huwilp Government had earlier withdrawn its support for the KSM project following the original ruling.

Timeline

  1. July 2024: Province granted the Substantial Start Determination for the KSM mine.

  2. June 2026: Original court ruling in favour of the Tsetsaut Skii km Lax Ha Nation.

  3. Nov. 18, 2026: Court confirmed key elements of the June ruling.

  4. Nov. 19, 2026: Seabridge Gold shares hit a fresh 52-week low.

Legal Context

The ruling applies Canada's constitutional duty to consult Indigenous nations to a Substantial Start Determination, reinforcing that provincial approvals granted without adequate consultation can be set aside. The decision places the KSM mine within a growing body of British Columbia resource litigation centred on that duty.

The ruling means the Province must complete deep consultation with the Tsetsaut Skii km Lax Ha Nation before the KSM project can proceed under the current approval. For residents and investors, the decision introduces timing uncertainty into a major development in northwestern British Columbia.

The takeaway

Approvals for major resource projects in British Columbia remain open to legal challenge when Indigenous consultation falls short. Investors and communities should watch how the Province structures the required deep consultation.

Further reading

For more on the legal framework behind this decision, see Law coverage of British Columbia.