Court Rules Prison Not Liable in Inmate Stabbing
A B.C. Supreme Court judge dismissed a former inmate's negligence claim against the Correctional Service of Canada over a 2016 stabbing at Matsqui Institution.
Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Criminal Justice

Justice Kevin Loo of the B.C. Supreme Court found the Correctional Service of Canada not liable for negligence after Nolan Swallow was stabbed by a fellow inmate at Matsqui Institution in Abbotsford in 2016. The court dismissed Swallow's action against the federal agency.
Why it matters
The ruling clarifies how far federal prison authorities are required to protect inmates from attacks by other prisoners. It bears on the duty of care owed by correctional staff when they release inmates from cells and when they respond to suspicious activity.
The B.C. Supreme Court has dismissed Nolan Swallow's negligence action against the Correctional Service of Canada, so the case is concluded at trial level. Whether an appeal will be filed has not been reported.
The players
Correctional Service of Canada
The federal agency responsible for managing federal penitentiaries and supervising offenders serving sentences of two years or more across Canada.
Justice Kevin Loo
A judge of the Supreme Court of British Columbia who heard and decided the negligence action brought by Nolan Swallow.
The details
Swallow, who was serving a manslaughter sentence, had been attacked by another inmate with a homemade ice pick in June 2016. In November 2016, after he was paged for a day parole release, a fellow inmate called the second-floor control post claiming an appointment, was released from his cell without confirmation, and stabbed Swallow as he walked past; a corrections officer witnessed the attack and ordered the attacker to stop. Swallow argued the agency breached its duty of care by releasing the inmate without a valid reason and failing to intervene while he loitered.
Timeline
December 2012: Swallow was incarcerated at Matsqui Institution to serve a manslaughter sentence.
June 25, 2016: Swallow was attacked by another inmate wielding a homemade ice pick.
November 14, 2016: Swallow was stabbed by a fellow inmate after being released from his cell.
November 16, 2026: Justice Kevin Loo ruled the Correctional Service of Canada not liable.
Legal Context
The decision applies the established common-law duty of care that Canadian courts have long applied to the state's custody of prisoners to a single stabbing at a federal prison. It shows how the same framework can produce a finding of no liability when a correctional officer intervened once the attack was observed.
The ruling affects how negligence claims against federal prisons are assessed, which matters to inmates and their families who may seek damages after violence in custody. It does not change day-to-day conditions for residents of Abbotsford or other communities near Matsqui Institution.
The takeaway
Claims that a prison failed to protect an inmate turn on the specific steps staff took before and during an attack. Anyone following similar cases should look at what the institution knew, what it did, and how quickly it responded.
Further reading
Explore more criminal justice coverage for British Columbia.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Today in BC.






