Judge Rules 25-Year Parole Wait Unconstitutional
B.C. Supreme Court found mandatory parole ineligibility for life sentences violates the Charter, a decision the Crown plans to challenge.
Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Criminal Justice

Live Poll
Should judges be allowed to override mandatory minimum prison sentences?
On October 19, Justice Brenda Brown of the B.C. Supreme Court in Abbotsford ruled that the mandatory 25-year parole ineligibility period for a life sentence is grossly disproportionate and violates section 12 of the Charter. The ruling arose in the case of one of three men from Surrey found guilty on May 8 of two counts of first-degree murder each, in the killings of Arnold and Joanne De Jong.
Why it matters
Justice Brown held that the law cannot account for the circumstances of why someone commits two murders or for rehabilitation that may occur before 25 years, which affects how life sentences apply across B.C. The Crown has said it will challenge the decision under section 1 of the Charter, so the ruling's reach remains open.
The three men were found guilty on May 8 of two counts of first-degree murder each, and the judge is expected to rule on their sentences on February 22. The Crown's section 1 challenge to the Charter ruling has not yet been heard, with arguments set for the new year.
The players
Justice Brenda Brown
Justice Brenda Brown is a judge of the B.C. Supreme Court who ruled that the mandatory 25-year parole ineligibility for life sentences violates the Charter.
B.C. Supreme Court
The B.C. Supreme Court is the province's superior trial court, which heard the Charter challenge in Abbotsford.
The details
The three men applied to have the law reconsidered in their case and to have the waiting period reduced before they can apply for parole. Justice Brown's reasons, posted online on November 16, draw on the 2017 Quebec mosque shooting case, in which the Quebec Court of Appeal set a 25-year parole ineligibility for Alexandre Bissonnette and the Supreme Court of Canada upheld it.
Timeline
May 9, 2022: Arnold and Joanne De Jong were found dead in their Abbotsford home.
May 8: Three men were found guilty of two first-degree murders each.
October 19: Justice Brown issued the Charter ruling on parole ineligibility.
November 16: The reasons for the ruling were posted online.
February 22: The judge is expected to rule on the sentences for the three men.
Legal Context
The B.C. ruling departs from the Supreme Court of Canada's decision upholding Alexandre Bissonnette's 25-year parole ineligibility after the 2017 Quebec mosque shooting. It places the constitutionality of mandatory life-sentence parole periods back before Canadian courts.
The ruling could change when people convicted of multiple murders in B.C. become eligible to apply for parole, affecting the timing of parole hearings. Until the Crown's appeal is resolved, the 25-year rule still governs many cases across the province.
The takeaway
Mandatory sentencing rules are being tested in court, so the parole timelines for serious offenders may shift depending on how the Crown's challenge is decided. Readers following the case should watch for the February 22 sentencing decision and the new-year hearing on the section 1 argument.
What happens next
The judge is expected to rule on the sentences for the three men on February 22, and arguments on the Crown's section 1 challenge will be heard in the new year.
Further reading
For more on how courts are reviewing sentencing rules, see Criminal Justice coverage across British Columbia.
Live Poll
Should judges be allowed to override mandatory minimum prison sentences?






