Court of Appeal Upholds $1 Million Payment Order
A Maple Ridge commercial property owner must pay a restoration contractor more than $1 million in unpaid invoices after a fire-damage project, the B.C. Court of Appeal has ruled.
Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Law

The British Columbia Court of Appeal unanimously upheld a judgment ordering a Maple Ridge commercial property owner to pay Canstar Restorations Limited Partnership $1,038,549.15 in unpaid invoices, plus interest at 24% a year. The appeal addressed only whether the payment claim was properly decided through a summary trial.
Why it matters
The ruling confirms that a contractor's payment claim can be resolved on written evidence in a summary trial, even when the property owner disputes the quality of the work. The defendant's separate counterclaim alleging defective work remains unresolved and untested at trial.
The Court of Appeal's unanimous decision upholds the original judgment, leaving the payment order in place. The defendant's counterclaim for defective work has not been decided and remains outstanding.
The details
A fire damaged the defendant's commercial premises in Maple Ridge on December 31, 2020. After an engineering consultant audited Canstar's invoices, the property owner's insurer, Gore Mutual Insurance Company, paid the full invoice amount, and the defendant signed a one-page work authorization on January 7, 2021, requiring payment within 30 days of each invoice. The trial judge found the owner had credibility concerns and excluded an expert report the defendant submitted; the defendant never raised its subtraction argument at trial.
Timeline
December 31, 2020: Fire damages the commercial premises in Maple Ridge.
January 7, 2021: The defendant signs the one-page work authorization.
November 18, 2026: The B.C. Court of Appeal upholds the judgment.
Legal Context
The decision shows how British Columbia courts can resolve commercial payment claims on written evidence through a summary trial, without a full hearing. It affirms that a counterclaim for defective work does not by itself prevent a payment order from being enforced.
Businesses that contract for repair work in British Columbia may find this ruling relevant to how payment terms and written work authorizations are enforced. Property owners who dispute invoices should understand that a counterclaim does not automatically stop a payment order.
The takeaway
Written work authorizations with clear payment terms can be decisive in commercial disputes. Parties disputing invoices should raise all arguments and evidence at trial, since unraised arguments may not succeed on appeal.
Further reading
For related rulings, browse recent Law coverage on Wisevoter.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Insurance Business.






