Vermont Families Sue Over School-Choice Tuition Exclusion
Five Vermont families challenge a residence-based rule that bars them from using public tuition dollars at local independent schools.
Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Homeschooling

Live Poll
Should families be able to use public school tuition funds at any public school, regardless of town?
Five Vermont parents filed a lawsuit against the state on Monday, November 16, in the Vermont Superior Court's Civil Division, in the case Duquette v. State of Vermont, et al. The complaint targets the Exclusion Rule, which bars families in towns with their own public schools from the tuitioning program.
Why it matters
The rule means families in towns with a local public school cannot use public education dollars at other public or approved independent schools, while families in towns without one can. The complaint argues the residence-based line violates the Education Clause and Common Benefits Clause of the Vermont Constitution, a question that could affect school-choice access statewide.
The lawsuit seeks a court declaration that the residence-based exclusion is unconstitutional and a permanent injunction blocking enforcement against the plaintiffs and other affected families. Four school-age children are named in one plaintiff's request to attend public schools in Colchester or South Burlington.
The players
Liberty Justice Center
The Liberty Justice Center is a nonprofit public-interest law firm that litigates civil liberties and parental-rights cases, and its PARENTS Initiative brought this challenge.
State of Vermont
The State of Vermont is the defendant, and its Exclusion Rule governs which families may use public tuition dollars at independent schools.
The details
The complaint was brought by the Liberty Justice Center's PARENTS Initiative and argues the exclusion violates the Vermont Constitution. Plaintiffs describe a range of circumstances, including concerns about academic standards at a local district, families paying out of pocket for public-school participation, and parents who turned to independent schools when assigned districts could not meet their children's needs.
Timeline
Monday, November 16, 2026: Five Vermont parents file the lawsuit in Vermont Superior Court's Civil Division.
Legal Landscape
The complaint turns on the Education Clause and Common Benefits Clause of the Vermont Constitution, so the court's reading of those provisions will determine whether the residence-based line survives. The outcome will shape how Vermont's public education dollars can flow to independent schools.
Families in towns with a public school should note that the current exclusion rule limits their use of public tuition dollars at independent schools. Parents weighing options should watch for the court's ruling, which will determine whether those restrictions remain in place.
The takeaway
The case asks whether a residence-based line can determine who gets to use public education dollars for independent schooling. Families considering school options should track the court's decision, since it could change which tuition choices are available.
Further reading
For more on home-based learning options, see Homeschooling coverage.
Live Poll
Should families be able to use public school tuition funds at any public school, regardless of town?










