Court Limits Dismissal Ruling in Murder Case

The Vermont Supreme Court says a trial judge should have weighed Sauve factors before permanently ending a 2019 death prosecution in Bennington County.

Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Sex Crimes

Court Limits Dismissal Ruling in Murder Case

The Vermont Supreme Court issued a unanimous ruling on Friday holding that a trial court had authority to dismiss a case with prejudice but should have considered the Sauve factors first. The ruling concerns a 36-year-old Bennington County man charged in 2022 with second-degree murder in the 2019 death of a 43-year-old New York woman.

Why it matters

The decision clarifies how Vermont trial courts must weigh factors before permanently ending a prosecution, a step that can bar future charges. It also sends the murder case back into the legal process rather than closing it.

The murder charge remains under the Vermont Supreme Court's direction that the trial court must weigh the Sauve factors before deciding whether to dismiss with prejudice. The defendant is in federal custody following a June 2025 sentence of 12½ years on federal drug and firearms charges, and the state murder case's next procedural step has not been set.

The players

Vermont Supreme Court

The state's highest court, which issued the unanimous ruling requiring consideration of the Sauve factors before permanent dismissal.

Judge Kerry McDonald-Cady

The Vermont trial judge who dismissed the murder charge with prejudice and ruled the prosecution's delay request unreasonable.

The details

The prosecution had sought a delay in early 2025 to complete expedited DNA testing before trial, and the judge ruled the delay unreasonable. The prosecution then moved to dismiss without prejudice, and the defense moved to dismiss with prejudice, with the judge concluding the state was improperly trying to grant itself the continuance the court had denied.

Timeline

  1. 2019: Remains allegedly found near an abandoned gravel pit in Searsburg.

  2. 2022: Charged with second-degree murder.

  3. Early 2025: Prosecution requested a delay for DNA testing; request denied.

  4. June 2025: Sentenced to 12½ years on federal charges.

  5. Friday, November 13, 2026: Vermont Supreme Court issues unanimous ruling.

Legal Context

The ruling applies the framework from State v. Sauve (1995), which requires Vermont trial courts to weigh specific factors before permanently ending a prosecution. The decision reinforces that dismissal with prejudice is a serious sanction that must be justified against that standard, even in a serious homicide case.

Residents of Bennington County and surrounding communities may see the murder case continue through the courts following the trial court's reconsideration. The ruling also affects how future prosecutions in Vermont handle requests for delay and dismissal with prejudice.

The takeaway

Dismissing a prosecution with prejudice is a permanent step that courts must justify with careful weighing, not a shortcut around a contested delay. Readers following criminal cases should watch whether the trial court's reconsideration results in a trial or a final resolution.

Further reading

For related coverage, see Sex Crimes reporting across the state.

Source note: This article includes information reported by VTDigger.