Lawsuit Challenges Trump Monument Shrinking Orders
Conservation groups are challenging executive orders that cut Grand Staircase-Escalante and Bears Ears National Monuments by about 3 million acres.
Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in National Parks

Live Poll
Should presidents be able to shrink national monuments by executive order?
President Trump signed two executive orders in July shrinking Grand Staircase-Escalante and Bears Ears National Monuments by around 3 million acres total, reducing them to about one tenth of their previous size. In September, conservation groups filed a lawsuit arguing the Antiquities Act of 1906 does not authorize such reductions by executive order.
Why it matters
The case will test whether a president can legally shrink national monuments, a question that has shaped federal land policy since 1906. Utah's federal delegation backed the move, while the Utah Democratic Party and environmental groups opposed it.
The two executive orders cut roughly 3 million acres, about 90% of the monuments' prior size, according to the extraction. Whether the Antiquities Act permits such reductions has not yet been decided by a court.
The players
Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance
A Utah-based conservation organization that advocates for the protection of wild public lands in southern Utah and is a plaintiff in the lawsuit.
President Donald Trump
The 47th President of the United States, who signed the executive orders shrinking the two national monuments.
The details
The executive orders, signed in July, shrank both monuments, and in September the Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance, Grand Canyon Trust, Sierra Club, Patagonia and the Natural Resources Defense Council sued. The groups argue the Antiquities Act does not authorize shrinking monuments through executive action. Proponents contend the move returns the monuments to the Act's requirements and allows more local input on the lands.
Timeline
July 2025: President Trump signs executive orders shrinking the monuments.
September 2025: Conservation groups file a lawsuit challenging the orders.
November 17, 2026: Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance scheduled to announce next steps at 11 a.m.
Legal Context
The lawsuit tests the reach of the Antiquities Act of 1906, the statute that first allowed presidents to designate national monuments by proclamation. In 2017 Trump shrank the monuments, and in 2021 President Joe Biden restored their acreage, making the current dispute a repeat of the same legal fight.
Visitors planning trips to the Grand Staircase-Escalante and Bears Ears areas should note that protections on these lands are currently in dispute. Travelers may want to check current land-management designations before booking trips to affected areas.
The takeaway
The outcome of this lawsuit will determine how much of Utah's protected public land can be altered by executive action rather than congressional decision. Travelers and residents alike should watch the case for changes to access at these monuments.
What happens next
The Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance is scheduled to announce its next steps on November 17, 2026, at 11 a.m.
Further reading
Explore more on National Parks to see how federal protections shape Utah's landscapes.
Live Poll
Should presidents be able to shrink national monuments by executive order?






