Appeals Court Weighs Utah Voter Records Access

The Tenth Circuit heard arguments on how much voter data the government must release under federal law.

Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Elections

Appeals Court Weighs Utah Voter Records Access

Live Poll

Do you trust state governments to keep voter records accurate and open?

The United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit heard arguments Monday on the breadth of voter records the government must release under the National Voter Registration Act. The case was brought by Phil Lyman, a former Utah state legislator, after a district court sided with Lieutenant Governor Deidre Henderson in January.

Why it matters

A ruling would bind federal courts in Colorado, Kansas, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Utah and Wyoming on how far voter-roll disclosure extends. Lyman says he requested the records to determine whether Utah's voter roll complies with federal and state law.

Lyman estimates he received about 60% of the voter records he requested, with records classified as private and dates of birth withheld. The Tenth Circuit has not yet issued a decision, and the court is not expected to rule Tuesday.

The players

Deidre Henderson

Utah's Lieutenant Governor, who oversees the state's elections and was the defendant in the voter records case.

Phil Lyman

A former Utah state legislator who ran in the 2024 Republican primary for governor and filed the records lawsuit.

Spencer Cox

Utah's Governor, who is also named in the case as a public official connected to the state's election administration.

The details

Lyman's complaint argues the denial of the requested records is itself the injury. His attorney, Kaylan Phillips of the Public Interest Legal Foundation, presented that argument at oral arguments. Lyman appealed the January district court decision that dismissed his suit.

Timeline

  1. August 2024: Lyman petitioned to annul the Republican primary results, a petition the Utah Supreme Court rejected.

  2. January 2026: A district court sided with Henderson and dismissed Lyman's lawsuit.

  3. November 16, 2026: The Tenth Circuit heard oral arguments in the records case.

  4. November 17, 2026: The court is not expected to issue a ruling on the appeal.

Political Context

The case asks how far the National Voter Registration Act's disclosure provisions reach, a question with direct consequences for how states handle voter-roll requests. Opponents of broad disclosure have argued that privacy protections limit what election records can be released.

Voters in Utah and five other states may see the outcome affect how their voter rolls are reviewed and what personal information is disclosed. The decision will determine how much election data citizens can request to check voter roll compliance.

The takeaway

Access to voter records is shaped by federal disclosure law and privacy limits, and the Tenth Circuit's ruling will set the boundary for six states. Readers following election administration should watch for the appeal decision.

Further reading

Explore more on Utah Elections coverage for background on the state's voter roll disputes.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Colorado Public Radio.

Live Poll

Do you trust state governments to keep voter records accurate and open?