Texas Ranks Among Least Affordable Insurance Markets

A Triple-I issues brief finds Texas homeowners and drivers face high premium costs relative to median income.

Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Insurance

Texas Ranks Among Least Affordable Insurance Markets

Live Poll

Do you think home and auto insurance costs are getting worse in your area?

The Insurance Information Institute released an issues brief finding Texas has among the least affordable property/casualty insurance markets in the U.S. The brief points to Florida's litigation reforms as a model for Texas.

Why it matters

Texas residents spend about 4.1% of median income on homeowners premiums and 1.9% on personal auto premiums, and the brief ties rising costs to severe weather losses, claims litigation and rapid population growth.

Texas commercial auto direct incurred loss and DCC ratio was 86.6% in 2025, third-highest in the U.S., while general liability was 86.3%, sixth-highest. Average Texas lightning losses reached $60,382 per claim in 2025, compared with a national average of $26,616.

The players

Insurance Information Institute (Triple-I)

Triple-I is a nonprofit property/casualty insurance industry research organization that publishes data-driven analysis on insurance markets and affordability.

The details

Triple-I attributes Texas's cost pressures to tornadoes and hailstorms, where Texas ranked first in 2025, along with claims litigation and population growth, the second-highest rate among states. A Perryman Group study found nuclear verdicts raise Texas property/casualty costs by at least 15.25%, and Texas ranked third nationally in verdicts of $10 million or more, totaling $3.4 billion in 2025.

Timeline

  1. 2020: Texas homeowners premium-to-income ratio stood at 2.86%.

  2. 2022 and 2023: Florida enacted legislative litigation reforms.

  3. 2024: Texas recorded 4,160 motor vehicle fatalities, the most of any state.

  4. 2025: Texas nuclear verdicts totaled $3.4 billion and Florida recorded only a statewide average property rate decrease.

Florida Model

Florida enacted litigation reforms in 2022 and 2023, and in 2025 the state recorded only a statewide average property rate decrease, which Triple-I cites as the benchmark Texas could emulate. Texas's 4.07% homeowners premium-to-income ratio in 2025 compares with 2.86% in 2020.

Texas homeowners and drivers face premium costs that consume a larger share of household income than in many states, with homeowners premiums alone taking about 4.1% of median income. Lightning and hail losses also feed into these costs, which can affect what policyholders pay at renewal.

The takeaway

Reviewing your homeowners and auto coverage at each renewal can help you compare premiums against your budget, since Texas rates are rising faster than income in many households. Ask your agent which discounts and coverage levels apply to your situation.

Further reading

For broader context on premium pricing, explore Insurance coverage trends across the state.

Source note: This article includes information reported by InsuranceNewsNet.

Live Poll

Do you think home and auto insurance costs are getting worse in your area?