Tennessee Patrol Settles Sober DUI Arrest for $70,000

The state Board of Claims approved a $70,000 settlement to Stefanie Fair, who alleged she was arrested for DUI while sober.

Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in R&B

Tennessee Patrol Settles Sober DUI Arrest for $70,000

Live Poll

Do you trust police in your area to get DUI arrests right?

The Tennessee Highway Patrol will pay $70,000 to Stefanie Fair to settle a lawsuit over her DUI arrest, which blood work showed occurred while she was sober. The state Board of Claims approved the settlement, with payout expected within weeks.

Why it matters

Fair is the second sober driver to sue the Tennessee Highway Patrol and reach a settlement, following a $75,000 payment to Thomas Manis after an East Tennessee DUI arrest. The cases raise questions for Tennessee residents about how DUI arrests are made and reviewed by state troopers.

Blood work showed Fair was sober at her 2024 arrest, which WSMV4 Investigates featured in its "Sobering Problem" reporting. Trooper Keith Velez said he smelled alcohol during the stop.

The players

Tennessee Highway Patrol

The state law enforcement agency whose troopers made the DUI arrests and which has now settled with two sober drivers.

Stefanie Fair

A former member of the 1990s pop group Wild Orchid who was arrested for DUI in 2024 and received the $70,000 settlement.

Trooper James Zahn

A Tennessee Highway Patrol trooper who is accused in a pending lawsuit of arresting sober drivers, including a Thompson Station man and Jane Bondurant.

Rutherford County Sheriff's Office

The county law enforcement agency that has settled lawsuits from sober drivers arrested for DUI.

La Vergne police

The city police department in Rutherford County that has also settled lawsuits from sober drivers arrested for DUI.

The details

Stefanie Fair, a former member of the 1990s pop group Wild Orchid, sued the Tennessee Highway Patrol over her 2024 DUI arrest. Trooper Keith Velez said he smelled alcohol during the arrest, but blood work showed she was sober, and the state Board of Claims has now approved a $70,000 settlement.

Timeline

  1. 2024: Fair is arrested for DUI by the Tennessee Highway Patrol.

  2. This year: A Thompson Station man files a lawsuit alleging Trooper James Zahn arrested him for DUI while sober.

  3. November 18, 2026: The settlement is reported publicly.

  4. Within the next few weeks: The $70,000 payout to Fair is expected.

Legal Context

Fair's settlement follows the earlier $75,000 payment to Thomas Manis and is part of a series of cases in which Tennessee law enforcement agencies have paid sober drivers arrested for DUI. The pattern of settlements from the Highway Patrol, the Rutherford County Sheriff's Office and La Vergne police points to a recurring problem in how DUI arrests are made across the state.

Tennessee drivers arrested for DUI may face similar questions about how their arrests are documented and reviewed. The settlements show that sober drivers can seek compensation through the state Board of Claims.

The takeaway

State settlements in sober DUI cases show that documented blood work can be used to challenge trooper arrests. Drivers who believe they were wrongly arrested can pursue claims through the Tennessee Board of Claims.

Further reading

For more on the music career behind the case, see R&B.

Source note: This article includes information reported by WAND-TV.

Live Poll

Do you trust police in your area to get DUI arrests right?