Audit Finds Highway Patrol Evidence Reviews Largely Flawed

A Tennessee Comptroller audit found only 41% of required Tennessee Highway Patrol evidence reviews from 2023 to 2025 were performed correctly.

Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Law Enforcement

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of stacked sealed evidence boxes on steel shelving, rendered in deep red and cream, evoking the custody records examined in a state evidence audit.
The Tennessee Comptroller's Office found the Tennessee Highway Patrol performed only 41% of 126 required evidence reviews correctly from 2023 to 2025. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

The Tennessee Comptroller's Office found that the Tennessee Highway Patrol performed 41% of 126 required evidence reviews correctly between 2023 and 2025. Auditors reported that 40 reviews were not performed at all and 34 were performed incorrectly.

Why it matters

Evidence reviews are meant to keep property and records accurate in criminal cases, and the audit's findings point to gaps in how the state's largest law enforcement agency handles that work. The findings matter for oversight of evidence custody across Tennessee.

placeholder

The players

Tennessee Highway Patrol

The Tennessee Highway Patrol is the state police agency responsible for state highway law enforcement and related evidence handling across Tennessee.

Tennessee Comptroller's Office

The Tennessee Comptroller's Office is the state agency that audits government operations and conducted this evidence review audit.

The details

Auditors evaluated review records and case files, and found 24 improperly performed reviews lacked proof the reviewer examined the related files. The comptroller's office said the THP manual spreads evidence review requirements across sections and is not especially clear, and management told auditors staff were unsure who was responsible.

Timeline

  1. 2023 to 2025: Period in which 126 required evidence reviews were evaluated.

  2. November 17, 2026: WVLT published the audit findings from its Knoxville report.

Legal Context

placeholder

Residents whose cases pass through Tennessee Highway Patrol evidence custody depend on accurate review records to protect the integrity of investigations. The audit's findings show that gaps in these reviews could affect how evidence is tracked for people involved in state highway cases.

The takeaway

Strong oversight of evidence handling depends on clear written rules and defined responsibility for each review step. The audit suggests that without both, required checks can be skipped or performed incorrectly.

Further reading

Explore more on Tennessee law enforcement coverage for context on how state agencies handle evidence and oversight.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Wvlt.