Five Candidates Vie for Open South Carolina Supreme Court Seat
A judicial screening panel heard from five candidates for the seat vacated by John Few, with lawmakers set to elect a successor in March.
Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Politics

Live Poll
Should state lawmakers, rather than voters, choose South Carolina's Supreme Court justices?
Five candidates are running for the open South Carolina Supreme Court seat left by John Few, who dropped out of the restarted race after it became clear he did not have the votes. Jay Lucas chose not to run in the new contest.
Why it matters
South Carolina is one of two states where legislators elect judges, so the outcome rests with the Legislature rather than voters. The candidate field includes Maite Murphy, Blake A. Hewitt, Eugene C. Griffith Jr., John D. Geathers, and Ralph K. Anderson III, and Geathers is the only Black judge among them, at a time when no Black justices sit on the state's high court.
The judicial screening panel held hearings on November 16, 2026, and the Legislature will elect the next justice in a vote scheduled for March 3, 2027. Lawmakers' final choice will depend on votes that have not yet been disclosed.
The players
John Few
John Few is a South Carolina Supreme Court justice who joined the 2023 decision striking down the state's six-week abortion ban and later exited the race for the open seat.
John D. Geathers
John D. Geathers is a South Carolina judge and Supreme Court candidate who joined a 2020 dissent penned by former Chief Justice Donald Beatty.
Donald Beatty
Donald Beatty is a former Chief Justice of the South Carolina Supreme Court who wrote a 2020 dissent in a drug trafficking case.
The details
The 12-person panel of lawmakers and attorneys that assesses judicial candidates' qualifications questioned the five candidates. Few joined the 2023 decision striking down the state's six-week abortion ban, and Geathers joined a 2020 dissent penned by former Chief Justice Donald Beatty in a drug trafficking case.
Timeline
2020: Geathers joined a dissent in a drug trafficking case.
2023: Few joined the decision striking down the six-week abortion ban.
November 16, 2026: Judicial screening hearings for the Supreme Court candidates were held.
January 26, 2027: The panel is scheduled to send its nominations to the Legislature.
March 3, 2027: Lawmakers will hold the election for the seat.
Political Context
The contest follows the 2023 South Carolina Supreme Court decision striking down the six-week abortion ban, after which Republicans passed a new version of the ban. Few's role in that ruling is part of the backdrop to a race the Legislature will decide.
Because legislators rather than voters pick South Carolina's justices, residents' influence runs through their state lawmakers. The outcome will shape how the state's high court rules on issues such as abortion and criminal law for years.
The takeaway
Residents who want a say in who sits on South Carolina's Supreme Court should follow their state legislators, since the Legislature makes the final choice in March 2027.
What happens next
The judicial screening panel will send its nominations to the Legislature on January 26, 2027, and lawmakers will hold the election on March 3, 2027.
Further reading
For more on how the state chooses its judges, see South Carolina Law coverage.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Post and Courier.
Live Poll
Should state lawmakers, rather than voters, choose South Carolina's Supreme Court justices?






