Township Approves Rutter's Liquor License Transfer
West Manchester Township unanimously approved moving a liquor license to a Rutter's store at 2115 Bannister St. after a public hearing.
Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Business

Live Poll
Should towns approve new alcohol sales near schools in your community?
West Manchester Township officials unanimously approved transferring a liquor license to the Rutter's store at 2115 Bannister St. CHR Corp., which does business as Rutter's Farm Stores, bought the license at auction earlier this year.
Why it matters
The vote follows a separate denial by Shrewsbury borough officials of CHR Corp.'s attempt to move the same license, a decision that has been appealed to the York County Court of Common Pleas. The outcome shows how license transfers across municipal lines can be contested in the York area.
CHR Corp. paid $200,670 for a restaurant license at a June auction of excess licenses, and transferring that license to another county carries a $50,000 fee. The York County Court of Common Pleas has yet to rule on the appeal of the Shrewsbury denial.
The players
CHR Corp. (Rutter's Farm Stores)
CHR Corp. is the company operating Rutter's Farm Stores, a convenience store chain in central Pennsylvania that has sought liquor licenses across several municipalities.
The details
Rutter's attorney said customers consistently want alcohol and the company aims for uniform offerings across its stores. Township Supervisor Felicia Dell said denying the license would be punitive when other businesses closer to the school already sell alcohol. Rutter's must apply for the transfer within six months, and staff under 18 cannot handle alcoholic products.
Timeline
June 2026: CHR Corp. won two licenses at an auction of excess restaurant licenses.
August 2026: Borough officials denied the Shrewsbury store transfer after a three-hour hearing.
Nov. 12, 2026: West Manchester Township held a public hearing before the vote.
Nov. 16, 2026: Township unanimously approved the transfer to 2115 Bannister St.
Six months from approval: Deadline for Rutter's to apply for the transfer.
Market Landscape
Pennsylvania's auction system for excess restaurant licenses lets companies such as CHR Corp. acquire licenses and move them across county lines, subject to local approval. The Shrewsbury denial and pending appeal show how municipalities are testing the limits of that process.
If approved, the Bannister St. Rutter's store could begin selling beer and wine, giving local shoppers a new option for alcohol purchases. The approval also means residents near West York Area High School may see the change, though the store is about half a mile from the school.
The takeaway
Local license transfers can move across municipal lines but still depend on each community's approval, and contested decisions can take months to resolve in court.
What happens next
Rutter's has six months from approval to apply for the license transfer, a deadline that falls in mid-2027.
Further reading
Explore more local store openings and closings in the York Openings & Closings section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by York Daily Record.
Live Poll
Should towns approve new alcohol sales near schools in your community?






