Court Restores Teacher Fired Over Covid Testing

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled termination hearings require physically present school board members, voiding a Philadelphia teacher's firing.

Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Law

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a plain columned civic building facade with a single flagpole in navy, cream, and muted red, evoking a state court ruling on teacher firings.
The Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled Tuesday that school board members must physically attend teacher termination hearings, reinstating Philadelphia teacher Neil Follman with back pay. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you trust your local school board to act fairly when firing employees?

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court affirmed the reinstatement with back pay of Philadelphia teacher Neil Follman. The court ruled Section 1127 of the School Code requires board members to be physically present at termination hearings, and none attended his.

Why it matters

The decision establishes that board members must physically attend teacher termination hearings under state law, a procedural requirement that can void dismissals. A concurring justice noted the ruling leaves open how many members must be present, suggesting further litigation.

The ruling was decided 6-1 with Chief Justice Debra Todd writing the majority opinion and Justice P. Kevin Brobson dissenting. The minimum attendance threshold for board members remains unsettled.

The players

Pennsylvania Supreme Court

The state's highest court, which issued the ruling that termination hearings require physically present school board members.

Philadelphia School District

The public school district that fired teacher Neil Follman and whose board's termination process was voided by the court.

The details

Follman was fired in spring 2021 after refusing the district's weekly Covid-19 testing requirement, following a principal's recommendation and a hearing officer's agreement. The board's September 13, 2021 termination meeting was switched to virtual over Follman's objections, and only a hearing officer attended. The Pennsylvania Education Secretary rejected his appeal before the Commonwealth Court reversed that decision.

Timeline

  1. Spring 2021: Follman fired after refusing the weekly Covid-19 testing requirement.

  2. September 13, 2021: Scheduled board meeting for Follman's termination hearing, later made virtual.

  3. November 17, 2026: Pennsylvania Supreme Court issues its decision affirming reinstatement.

Legal Context

The decision interprets Section 1127 of Pennsylvania's School Code to require board members to be physically present at termination hearings. Justice Daniel McCaffery's concurrence notes the majority left open how many members must attend, guaranteeing future litigation.

Pennsylvania school boards must now ensure members physically attend teacher termination hearings or risk voided dismissals. Teachers facing firing gain a procedural safeguard that can restore their positions and back pay.

The takeaway

Procedural requirements in school termination law can determine outcomes regardless of the merits of a dismissal. Educators and administrators should confirm that hearing requirements are fully met before finalizing any termination.

Further reading

Explore more Pennsylvania law coverage for context on state court rulings.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Legal Newsline.

Live Poll

Do you trust your local school board to act fairly when firing employees?