Court Upholds Benefit Cut Under Revised Impairment Law
Commonwealth Court affirmed a shift from temporary total to temporary partial disability for a worker injured in 1991.
Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Law

Live Poll
Should injured workers keep full disability benefits no matter how old the injury is?
The Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court affirmed a downgrade of a worker's benefits from temporary total to temporary partial disability. The ruling holds that impairment evaluations under Act 111 apply to injuries that occurred before 1996.
Why it matters
The decision determines whether workers injured before the 1996 introduction of impairment ratings can have their benefits reduced under the 2018 law. It clarifies how Pennsylvania courts read provisions dropped from a law and later reenacted.
The Commonwealth Court affirmed the modification of benefits, and the case is concluded at this level. The worker's partial disability payments are capped at 500 weeks.
The players
Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania
The state appellate court that reviews decisions of the Pennsylvania Workers' Compensation Appeal Board and other state agencies.
Pennsylvania Supreme Court
The state's highest court, which in 2017 struck down the original impairment rating provisions for workers' compensation.
The details
The worker, a repair shop foreman injured in March 1991, underwent five surgeries and had modification attempts in 2001 and 2007 fail. The 2023 evaluation placed his impairment at 27%, which the court held falls under the Act 111 framework even though the injury predates the 1996 impairment provisions.
Timeline
March 1991: The worker injured his lower back.
1996: Pennsylvania introduced impairment rating evaluations.
2001 and 2007: Employer modification attempts failed.
2017: The state Supreme Court struck down the original impairment provisions.
2018: The legislature enacted Act 111 without a date restriction.
Legal Context
The decision follows the Pennsylvania Supreme Court's 2017 invalidation of the original impairment rating scheme and the legislature's 2018 rebuilding of it in Act 111. It shows how the state's courts treat provisions dropped from a statute and later reenacted.
Workers injured before 1996 in Pennsylvania may see their benefits reduced if an impairment evaluation falls below 35%. Employers can seek modification of benefits based on the revised law.
The takeaway
Benefit determinations for older injuries now turn on whether a current impairment evaluation meets the Act 111 threshold. Workers and employers should review how the 2018 law applies to their own claims.
Further reading
Explore more Pennsylvania law coverage for context on state court rulings.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Human Resources Director.
Live Poll
Should injured workers keep full disability benefits no matter how old the injury is?






