Appeals Court Rejects New Trial in Sexual Harassment Case

The Sixth Circuit found a former Ohio State University graduate student's arguments were either forfeited or baseless.

Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Crime

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a limestone courthouse facade with columns and a still flag, in deep red, cream, and slate grey.
A federal appeals court refused to order a new trial for a former Ohio State graduate student who alleged sexual harassment by her doctoral adviser, finding her arguments forfeited or baseless. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit rejected a request for a new trial from the complainant, a former Ohio State University graduate student who alleged sexual harassment by her doctoral faculty adviser. The court ruled on Tuesday that her arguments were either forfeited or baseless.

Why it matters

The ruling leaves the original jury verdict in place and underscores that parties must raise objections to jury instructions before a jury considers an issue. For Columbus and the Ohio State community, the decision highlights how university-based harassment claims are litigated under federal job bias law.

The Sixth Circuit affirmed the outcome of the trial by rejecting the request for a new trial, finding the complainant's arguments were forfeited or baseless. The filings do not indicate whether further appeals are planned.

The players

U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit

The federal appellate court covering Ohio, Michigan, Kentucky, Tennessee, and the Tennessee-based federal districts, which reviews appeals from U.S. district courts in its region.

Ohio State University

A public research university in Columbus, Ohio, and one of the largest universities in the United States, where the alleged harassment occurred.

The details

The complainant did not object to jury instructions on whether she qualified as an employee under federal job bias law before the jury considered that question. The appellate panel concluded that this failure to object, along with the other arguments raised, did not warrant a new trial.

Timeline

  1. Tuesday (week of November 17, 2026): Sixth Circuit panel rejected the request for a new trial.

Legal Context

The decision applies Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 to a graduate student's harassment claim, testing whether a student can be treated as an employee under federal job bias law. It also reinforces the appellate rule that objections to jury instructions must be raised before the jury deliberates.

Columbus students and employees at Ohio State can see how federal courts treat harassment claims arising in university settings. The ruling shows that procedural objections raised late can limit a party's ability to overturn a verdict.

The takeaway

Parties involved in trials should raise objections to jury instructions before the jury considers contested issues, because late objections are often forfeited on appeal. Students and employees who believe they have been harassed should document incidents and understand the reporting channels available through their institution.

Further reading

Explore more coverage in Sex Crimes reporting for Columbus readers.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Bloomberglaw.