Columbus Police Seek Leads in 2020 Sullivant Avenue Case
Authorities are renewing calls for information regarding the 2020 murder of James Johnson III at a Hilltop gas station.
Updated on Oct. 21, 2026 in Violence
Six years after the October 20, 2020, shooting that claimed the life of James Johnson III at a Sunoco station on Sullivant Avenue, the case remains unsolved. No suspect has been identified in the killing, which occurred in the Hilltop neighborhood.
Why it matters
Law enforcement is highlighting the unsolved homicide to generate new leads for an investigation that has lacked momentum. The victim leaves behind six children, and the community is being asked to assist in bringing closure to his family.
No detective is currently assigned to the active investigation into the shooting at 2281 Sullivant Avenue. Central Ohio Crime Stoppers is offering a cash reward for information leading to an arrest or indictment.
The players
James Johnson III
He was a victim of gun violence who left behind six children.
Central Ohio Crime Stoppers
This organization facilitates anonymous tip submissions to local law enforcement agencies.
The details
The victim was fatally wounded at a Sunoco gas station by two men who subsequently fled the scene. These individuals were observed escaping in a red-over-gold Pontiac Montana minivan driven by a female accomplice.
Timeline
October 20, 2020: The day James Johnson III was killed.
October 20, 2026: The six-year anniversary of the shooting.
Legal Context
This case highlights the difficulty of maintaining investigative momentum in historical shootings that fall outside of 2020 Columbus homicide investigation protocols. It follows a pattern of cold cases where community assistance becomes the primary path to justice.
Residents who may have information about the vehicle or the suspects are urged to call 614-461-8477. Providing details to investigators can lead to a cash reward and help resolve a case that has remained open for six years.
The takeaway
Unsolved cases often rely on renewed public awareness to uncover details that were previously missed by investigators. Residents are encouraged to report any recollections of the incident to help identify the suspects involved in the minivan.
Further reading
Find more updates on area safety and law enforcement efforts in the Columbus Violence section.
More information
Submit tips regarding the case through the Central Ohio Crime Stoppers tip submission.
