Syracuse Drops Effort to Tax Schine Student Center
The city ends its four-year push after a state court ruled the university building should not be taxed.
Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Law

Live Poll
Should Syracuse University pay more in taxes to support the city and its schools?
The city of Syracuse has dropped its effort to remove the tax-exempt status of Syracuse University's Schine Student Center. The New York State Supreme Court ruled on June 5 that the building should not be taxed, ending a four-year legal battle.
Why it matters
The Schine tax bill would have cost Syracuse University roughly $60,000 annually, but the outcome also shapes how the city can seek payments from the university. Syracuse's Payment in Lieu of Taxes agreement expired in June, and a renewal is being arranged.
The Schine tax bill would have cost Syracuse University roughly $60,000 annually. The city has previously collected $2 million from the university under a services agreement, while the terms of the new PILOT deal remain unsettled.
The players
Syracuse University
A private research university in Syracuse, New York, whose Schine Student Center was at the center of the tax-exemption dispute.
Sharon Owens
The mayor of Syracuse, who made the decision to drop the city's effort to tax the Schine Student Center.
Susan Katzoff
The city's corporation counsel, who fired attorney Trevor McDaniel nine days before oral arguments began.
Trevor McDaniel
A city attorney who was fired by corporation counsel Susan Katzoff nine days before oral arguments in the Schine case.
The details
The city's legal department asked the court to reconsider the decision or take it to a higher court, but the court denied the request on Oct. 2. Corporation Counsel Susan Katzoff fired attorney Trevor McDaniel nine days before oral arguments began, and the city sent no one to those arguments while the university did. Mayor Sharon Owens made the decision to drop the matter, citing legal strategy her administration did not elaborate on.
Timeline
June 5: New York State Supreme Court ruled Schine should not be taxed.
June: Syracuse University's Payment in Lieu of Taxes agreement expired.
Oct. 2: The court denied the city's request for reconsideration.
Nov. 16: The city dropped its effort to remove the tax-exempt status, reported Monday.
Legal Context
The dispute tests how far Syracuse can go in taxing university property under New York law, since the city's PILOT agreement with Syracuse University expired in June and its renewal is being arranged. The outcome of the Schine case will likely inform the terms of that new agreement.
For Syracuse residents, the outcome determines whether the university makes payments to the city and school district that fund local services. The new PILOT terms will decide how much of the university's property value contributes to the city's budget.
The takeaway
Tax-exempt status for university buildings can be decided in court, but payments to host cities are usually negotiated separately, so residents should watch the renewed PILOT agreement closely.
What happens next
A renewed Payment in Lieu of Taxes agreement between the city and Syracuse University is being arranged, with the auditor proposing $16 million a year in city taxes and $19 million for the school district.
Further reading
For more on how courts settle tax disputes with universities, see Law coverage across Syracuse.
Source note: This article includes information reported by The Daily Orange.
Live Poll
Should Syracuse University pay more in taxes to support the city and its schools?










