Yankees Weigh Rice and García in 2027 Lineup
New York could keep Ben Rice and Luis García Jr. in its lineup next season, with Paul Goldschmidt now a free agent.
Updated on Nov. 22, 2026 in Baseball

The Yankees could keep Ben Rice and Luis García Jr. in the 2027 lineup as Paul Goldschmidt becomes a free agent. Analysis published November 22, 2026 weighs how the two players might fit together.
Why it matters
With Goldschmidt off the market, New York must decide how to fill first base and second base, and whether García's final year of team control makes a trade worth considering. The choice affects both the infield alignment and the club's flexibility this winter.
Ben Rice has caught in 37 of his 342 major league games, and he made two appearances at first base in 2026 after New York acquired García from Washington. García, 26, hit 30 home runs in his first 30-homer season, but how the Yankees will allocate the two players in 2027 remains unresolved.
The players
Ben Rice
Rice is a New York Yankees player whom the club developed as a catcher before moving him toward first base.
Luis García Jr.
García is a 26-year-old infielder who came to New York from Washington in 2026 and hit 30 home runs in his first 30-homer season.
Paul Goldschmidt
Goldschmidt is a veteran first baseman who is now a free agent after sharing time at first base with García.
The details
Rice did not catch in 2026, and García shared first base with Goldschmidt, leaving Rice few chances to play there. Analysts say Rice at first and García at second is the likeliest alignment if both stay.
Timeline
2024: The Yankees brought Rice up to fill an opening at first base.
2026: Judge was injured and New York acquired García from Washington.
2027: García enters his final year under team control.
This winter: The Yankees could consider trading García.
Season Trajectory
The Yankees' 2026 injury to Aaron Judge drove the club to pursue Goldschmidt and acquire García, and the 2027 decisions extend that season's roster reshuffling. Rice and García now shape whether New York keeps its infield flexible or commits to a fixed alignment.
If García is traded, the Yankees would open second base and possibly change how the infield fits together next spring. Fantasy managers tracking Rice's catcher eligibility should note he has caught in only 37 of 342 major league games.
The takeaway
Roster decisions on first and second base this winter will show whether New York prioritizes fixed roles or infield flexibility heading into 2027. Watching how the club handles García's final year of control offers a clear signal of its plans.
Further reading
For more on the club's roster moves, see Baseball coverage in New York City.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Fingerlakes1.






