Giants Fear Cowboys More Than Commanders

New York fans see Dallas as the bigger threat to the Giants' NFC East lead after a Week 10 loss to Washington.

Updated on Nov. 22, 2026 in Football

Giants Fear Cowboys More Than Commanders

Live Poll

Do you think the Giants are heading in the right direction this season?

The New York Giants (5-3-1) lead the NFC East after losing to the Washington Commanders in Week 10. In a poll, Giants fans named the Dallas Cowboys (4-6), not the Commanders (3-5-1), as the bigger threat to the division lead.

Why it matters

The Giants trail nothing in the division but hold the head-to-head tiebreaker against Dallas only if results go their way, and the Commanders' tiebreaker over New York makes Washington a live factor. For New York readers, the Week 17 meeting with Dallas is the game fans are watching most closely.

Giants fan confidence in the team's direction fell from 97% to 90% after the Week 10 loss, while the Giants (5-3-1) sit 1.5 games ahead of the Cowboys (4-6) and the Commanders (3-5-1). Whether the Giants hold the division will depend on the Week 17 meeting with Dallas, and the poll does not measure how that game is expected to play out.

The players

New York Giants

A National Football League franchise based in the New York metropolitan area and a longtime member of the NFC East.

Dallas Cowboys

A National Football League franchise based in Arlington, Texas, and one of the most valuable sports teams in the world.

Washington Commanders

A National Football League franchise based in the Washington, D.C., area that competes in the NFC East.

The details

Asked which rival poses the bigger threat to the Giants' control of the NFC East, Giants fans named the Cowboys over the Commanders. The Giants lost to Washington in Week 10, and the Commanders hold the head-to-head tiebreaker over New York.

Timeline

  1. Week 10: Giants lose to the Washington Commanders.

  2. November 29 to December 20: Commanders face a four-game stretch against weaker opponents.

  3. Week 17: Giants and Cowboys play each other.

Season Trajectory

The NFC East race is being shaped by head-to-head tiebreakers, with Washington holding the edge over New York even as the Giants lead the standings. The Commanders' schedule over the next four weeks is considerably easier than the Giants' remaining slate, which includes the Jacksonville Jaguars, San Francisco 49ers, Seattle Seahawks and Detroit Lions.

For fantasy and season-ticket holders, the Week 17 Giants-Cowboys game and the Commanders' easier stretch of opponents from late November into December are the key scheduling facts to track. The Giants' -146 playoff price on FanDuel means the market already treats them as likely postseason qualifiers.

The takeaway

Fan worry often tracks the rival that has the most head-to-head games left, not the one that beat your team most recently. The Cowboys, not the Commanders, are the team that will determine the Giants' fate in the final weeks.

What happens next

The Giants and Cowboys meet in Week 17, which will likely decide much of the NFC East race.

Further reading

Follow the latest New York Giants storylines in our Football section.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Big Blue View.

Live Poll

Do you think the Giants are heading in the right direction this season?