Behrs, Radnor to Join Broadway's Schmigadoon! in 2027
Beth Behrs and Josh Radnor will take over as Melissa Gimble and Josh Skinner in limited six-week engagements.
Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Entertainment

Beth Behrs and Josh Radnor will join the Broadway production of Schmigadoon! at the Nederlander Theatre beginning January 19, 2027, each for a six-week limited engagement through February 28, 2027. Behrs will make her Broadway debut, succeeding original cast members Sara Chase and Alex Brightman, who take their final bows January 17, 2027.
Why it matters
The casting extends the run of the 2026 Tony Award winner for Best Musical, which opened April 20 at the Nederlander Theatre and is currently scheduled through April 4, 2027. The engagements give New York City theatergoers a new cast pairing during the show's extended run.
The production has won four Tony Awards, including Best Musical, Best Original Score, Best Book of a Musical, and Best Orchestrations. Whether the limited engagements will be extended was not addressed.
The players
Beth Behrs
Actress known for the CBS sitcom 2 Broke Girls, making her Broadway debut in Schmigadoon!.
Josh Radnor
Actor and writer best known for How I Met Your Mother, who made his Broadway debut in 2002's The Graduate.
Apple TV+
Streaming service that premiered Schmigadoon! in 2021 before canceling its third season during production.
The details
Behrs and Radnor will play Melissa Gimble and Josh Skinner, performing a stage adaptation that includes all songs from the series' Grammy-nominated score plus new titles, including songs cut from the show. Radnor made his Broadway debut in 2002's The Graduate, and the musical premiered on Apple TV+ in 2021 before Apple canceled its unfinished third season.
Timeline
April 20: Schmigadoon! opened at the Nederlander Theatre.
January 17, 2027: Sara Chase and Alex Brightman take their final bows.
January 19, 2027: Behrs and Radnor begin joining the production.
February 28, 2027: Behrs and Radnor's six-week engagements end.
April 4, 2027: The extended run is scheduled to end.
Industry Dynamics
The stage adaptation follows Apple TV+'s 2021 premiere and its cancellation of the unfinished third season, a pattern in which streaming series find second lives through live theater. Producer Paul's stated goal is to bring all three seasons of Schmigadoon to the stage, extending material the streamer did not complete.
Theatergoers in New York City can see Behrs and Radnor in their six-week engagements at the Nederlander Theatre from January 19 through February 28, 2027. Tickets for those specific dates will be the practical way to catch the new casting during the production's extended run.
The takeaway
Stage adaptations can give a cancelled streaming series a new life, and the Schmigadoon! casting shows how the production is being refreshed with new performers for its extended run. Anyone planning a Broadway visit in early 2027 should note the limited six-week engagements for each new cast member.
What happens next
Behrs and Radnor's engagements begin January 19, 2027, and the production's scheduled run ends April 4, 2027.
Further reading
For more on stage and screen crossovers, see our Television coverage.






