Schmigadoon! Stars Brightman, Chase to Exit in January
Michelle Visage will succeed Jennifer Simard as Mildred Layton on Broadway beginning December 4.
Updated on Nov. 13, 2026 in Children’s Theater

Alex Brightman and Sara Chase will leave Broadway's Schmigadoon! on January 17, 2027, after creating their roles and leading the musical as a real-world couple. Future casting for their roles is to be announced.
Why it matters
The departures mark a turnover for a Broadway production that has been one of the season's most decorated, and the musical is scheduled to play an extended run through April 4, 2027. For New York City theatergoers, the changes will affect which cast members they see in the show's remaining months.
Schmigadoon! took four Tony categories, including Best Musical, Best Original Score and Best Book of a Musical for Cinco Paul, and Orchestrations for Doug Besterman and Mike Morris. The replacement cast for the leads has not yet been named.
The players
Alex Brightman
Brightman is a Broadway performer who plays Josh Skinner in Schmigadoon! and helped create the role.
Sara Chase
Chase is a stage actress who plays Melissa Gimble in Schmigadoon! and helped create the role.
Michelle Visage
Visage is a television personality and performer who will take over the role of Mildred Layton.
Jennifer Simard
Simard is an actress who plays Mildred Layton in Schmigadoon! through December 1.
The details
Brightman and Chase play Josh Skinner and Melissa Gimble and will take their final bows at the Nederlander Theatre on January 17, 2027. The musical premiered in 2025 at Washington, D.C.'s Kennedy Center and opened on Broadway on April 20, 2026, after a run that began with its Apple TV+ debut in 2021.
Timeline
2021: Schmigadoon! premieres on Apple TV+.
2025: The stage musical premieres at the Kennedy Center in Washington, D.C.
April 20, 2026: The production opens at the Nederlander Theatre on Broadway.
December 4, 2026: Michelle Visage begins as Mildred Layton, succeeding Jennifer Simard.
January 17, 2027: Alex Brightman and Sara Chase leave the production.
Season Trajectory
Schmigadoon! ended the 2026 Tony Awards tied with The Lost Boys and Ragtime as the season's most-awarded musicals, each taking four categories. The lead departures arrive as the production heads into an extended run through April 2027.
Theatergoers planning to see the original leads should book performances before January 17, 2027, when Brightman and Chase depart. Tickets for the show's extended run through April 4, 2027 remain available through the Nederlander Theatre's box office.
The takeaway
Audiences who want to see Brightman and Chase in their original roles have a limited window that closes January 17, 2027. Checking the production's casting updates before booking can help avoid surprises as replacements are announced.
What happens next
Michelle Visage begins as Mildred Layton on December 4, 2026, and Brightman and Chase take their final bows on January 17, 2027.
Further reading
For more on family-friendly stage productions, explore Children's Theater coverage for New York City.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Playbill.






