Stella Cole Will Make Broadway Debut in Maybe Happy Ending
The performer will join the musical for a limited four-week run beginning October 20.
Updated on Oct. 1, 2026 in Arts Theater — General
Live Poll
Do you support casting performers regardless of gender in traditional Broadway roles?
Stella Cole will debut on Broadway in the role of Gil Brentley in the musical Maybe Happy Ending. She is set to begin her limited four-week run on October 20, 2026.
Why it matters
Stella Cole becomes the first woman to perform the role of Gil Brentley in the production, which will be pronounced Jill during her engagement. The casting move occurs while original cast member Dez Duron takes a temporary leave of absence.
Maybe Happy Ending opened at the Belasco Theatre on November 12, 2024, and secured nominations in 10 Tony categories for the 2024-2025 season.
The players
Stella Cole
She is a performer who is making her Broadway debut as the first woman to play the role of Gil Brentley.
Dez Duron
He is an actor in the Broadway production who is taking a temporary leave of absence.
Michael Arden
He is the director responsible for the staging of the musical Maybe Happy Ending.
The details
Director Michael Arden will oversee the production during the period in which Cole steps into the role of Brentley. Dez Duron is scheduled to return to his position within the company on November 17, 2026.
Timeline
November 12, 2024: The musical opened at the Belasco Theatre.
October 20, 2026: Stella Cole joins the Broadway cast.
November 15, 2026: The conclusion of Cole's four-week limited run.
November 17, 2026: Dez Duron re-joins the company.
Industry Dynamics
This casting change highlights the fluidity of Broadway companies following a successful awards cycle. It underscores how high-performing productions manage actor transitions to maintain the integrity of shows that garnered significant industry recognition.
Patrons planning to see the musical at the Belasco Theatre during the four-week window between October 20 and November 15 will see Stella Cole in the role of Gil Brentley. Those specifically wishing to see the original cast configuration should plan their visits for after November 17.
The takeaway
The addition of a new performer to a long-running show provides a fresh interpretation of established roles for returning audience members. Casting shifts are a standard aspect of Broadway production management that allow shows to extend their commercial runs.
Further reading
Find more updates on current shows in the Arts Theater section.
Live Poll
Do you support casting performers regardless of gender in traditional Broadway roles?
