Robert Wooten Testifies in New Rochelle Murder Trial
The defendant claims he shot Meisha Williams in self-defense at an apartment on Clinton Place.
Updated on Oct. 16, 2026 in Violence
Robert Wooten is on the stand in Westchester County Court, testifying that he fatally shot Meisha Williams in self-defense during an August 2024 encounter in New Rochelle. Prosecutors argue the killing was motivated by the victim's attempt to end their relationship.
Why it matters
The case hinges on whether Wooten's actions constitute justified self-defense or murder, as he was in violation of an order of protection at the time of the shooting. The victim had previously been arrested for stabbing Wooten in Virginia.
Robert Wooten faces a potential sentence of 15 to 25 years to life if convicted of second-degree murder. Police recovered five shell casings from the scene, and the defendant currently faces charges stemming from his arrest in Queens.
The players
Robert Wooten
The 30-year-old defendant is currently standing trial for the murder of Meisha Williams.
Meisha Williams
The victim was fatally shot at an apartment on Clinton Place in August 2024.
Westchester County Court
This judicial body is overseeing the murder trial of Robert Wooten.
The details
Wooten testified that he retrieved a gun from a purse and fired after Williams allegedly brandished a knife, fearing she would stab him in the head. He fled the New Rochelle scene in a Cadillac Escalade and did not call 911 after shooting the victim twice in the back.
Timeline
Robert Wooten and Meisha Williams met in late 2021.
Meisha Williams was arrested for stabbing Robert Wooten in May 2024.
The fatal shooting occurred on August 24, 2024.
Wooten testified during his murder trial the week of October 12, 2026.
Cross-examination of the defendant continues on October 16, 2026.
Legal Context
This case follows established New York legal guidelines for evaluating claims of self-defense during violent confrontations. The proceedings highlight how courts weigh historical domestic incidents against immediate threats when determining criminal liability.
The ongoing trial centers on a violent incident at 55 Clinton Place, which has drawn significant attention to safety protocols in local residential buildings. Residents are reminded that emergency services should be contacted immediately following any violent encounter.
The takeaway
Self-defense claims are rigorously scrutinized in court, especially when the defendant is found to be in violation of existing protection orders. The absence of a 911 call following a violent encounter can significantly complicate a defendant's narrative in the eyes of a jury.
Further reading
For more on criminal proceedings in the region, visit the Violence section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by The Journal News.
