Buffalo Relies on Overtime as Police Ranks Thin
No police exam was held in 2026, and the city's next recruitment class is not expected on patrol until 2028 at the earliest.
Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Law Enforcement

Live Poll
Do you think Buffalo's local government is handling police staffing well?
Buffalo did not schedule a police recruitment exam during Christopher Scanlon's tenure as acting mayor, and police overtime hours rose 65% in fiscal 2025-2026 compared with the prior year. The city's last exam was administered in 2023, and its recruit list is now exhausted.
Why it matters
With 19 officers retired and five resigned in 2026, and seven more planning to retire by year's end, Buffalo is relying on overtime to meet minimum staffing levels. The delay in recruitment affects public safety and city budgets in Buffalo, where officials cited fiscal challenges as a reason for not scheduling an exam.
The Buffalo Police Department's staffing shortfall is documented in department overtime and retirement figures, with 65% more overtime hours in FY 2025-2026 and 19 retirements and five resignations in 2026. The city has not yet confirmed how many officers from the Erie County recruit list it will hire.
The players
Christopher Scanlon
Scanlon served as acting mayor of Buffalo from October 2024 through December 2025, a period in which the city did not schedule a police recruitment exam.
Buffalo Police Department
The Buffalo Police Department is the municipal law enforcement agency serving Buffalo, New York, and is experiencing staffing shortages and rising reliance on overtime.
The details
Scanlon said the city's fiscal challenges, including a $70 million budget deficit when he became acting mayor in October 2024, were the reason no exam was scheduled for 2026, and that police exams take months to arrange, which was why none was administered in 2025. The city now plans to hire from Erie County's list of potential recruits, aiming to start a recruit class at the police academy in January.
Timeline
2023: The last police recruitment exam was administered.
October 2024: Christopher Scanlon became acting mayor of Buffalo.
2025: No police exam was administered.
FY 2025-2026: Police overtime hours increased 65% over the prior year.
December 2025: Scanlon's tenure as acting mayor ended.
Legal Context
Buffalo's dependence on overtime to meet minimum staffing follows from the 2023 police exam, whose recruit list is now exhausted and inactive. The city's plan to draw on Erie County's list of potential recruits marks a return to a regional pipeline after the local list ran dry.
Residents may see continued reliance on overtime-staffed patrols while the city works through its recruiting backlog. A fresh class of officers will not be on Buffalo's streets until 2028 at the earliest, so staffing levels are likely to stay thin in the near term.
The takeaway
Buffalo's staffing gap shows how a missed exam can take years to repair, since recruits hired now will not reach patrol until 2028. Tracking how the city fills its academy class in January will indicate whether the shortfall begins to ease.
What happens next
The city aims to put a class of recruits from the Erie County list into the police academy in January, and the next police exam is scheduled for the end of April 2027.
Further reading
For broader coverage of police staffing and public safety, see the Law Enforcement section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by WKBW.
Live Poll
Do you think Buffalo's local government is handling police staffing well?






