Audit Finds $5 Million Missing From Seneca Babcock Group
An Erie County Comptroller audit flags nearly $5 million in unaccounted transactions at a Buffalo neighborhood association from 2021 to 2025.
Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Philanthropy

Live Poll
Do you trust local nonprofits in your area to manage their money honestly?
The Erie County Comptroller found nearly $5 million of transactions missing from Seneca Babcock Community Association records covering 2021 to 2025. A former association chairman in Buffalo resigned after the audit raised questions about the organization's tax-exempt nonprofit status.
Why it matters
The findings raise accountability questions for a Buffalo neighborhood nonprofit that serves local residents and depends on tax-exempt status. The audit's recommendation for a new financial oversight plan points to how community organizations can strengthen controls on donated and program funds.
The Erie County Comptroller audit reports nearly $5 million in missing transactions from 2021 to 2025, measured against the association's own records. Whether the gap reflects recordkeeping failures or misuse of funds remains unresolved, as the audit states no revenue was stolen.
The players
Erie County Comptroller
The Erie County Comptroller is the county's chief fiscal officer, responsible for auditing county agencies and reviewing financial records submitted to the county.
Seneca Babcock Community Association
The Seneca Babcock Community Association is a Buffalo neighborhood nonprofit whose tax-exempt status and financial records are at the center of the audit.
The details
The Erie County Comptroller audited the Seneca Babcock Community Association and found some tax documents submitted to the county were questionable. Its 2019, 2020 and 2021 tax returns appear identical to its 2017 returns, and the audit recommends a new financial oversight plan for the group. Several of the association's services were suspended earlier this year.
Timeline
2017: Association tax returns used as the baseline for comparison.
2021 to 2025: Period in which nearly $5 million of transactions are missing.
Earlier in 2026: Several association services suspended.
November 18, 2026: Audit findings reported publicly.
Market Landscape
Local nonprofits in Erie County submit tax documents that the county comptroller can audit against prior-year filings, as this review did by comparing 2019 through 2021 returns to 2017. The case shows how repeated or identical filings can become a red flag during county oversight of community organizations.
Residents who rely on Seneca Babcock Community Association programs may face changes as the group adopts the audit's recommended financial oversight plan. Donors and taxpayers in Erie County can watch for how the county and association respond to the audit's findings on tax filings.
The takeaway
Tax-exempt community groups are expected to keep accurate, current financial records, and identical year-to-year filings can trigger scrutiny. Donors and neighbors should look for published audits and oversight plans before supporting local nonprofits.
Further reading
For related coverage, see Philanthropy reporting on how nonprofits manage donor and public funds.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Wivb4.
Live Poll
Do you trust local nonprofits in your area to manage their money honestly?










