Appeals Court Strikes Down Nassau Transgender Athlete Ban
A four-justice New York appellate panel ruled the county cannot override state human and civil rights protections through local law.
Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Law

Live Poll
Should transgender athletes be allowed to play on women's teams at county facilities?
A New York appeals court struck down Nassau County's ban on transgender athletes, ruling that the local law conflicts with and is preempted by state human rights and civil rights laws. The four-justice panel ruled in favor of New York Attorney General Letitia James' parallel legal challenge to the ban.
Why it matters
The ruling reinforces that counties cannot use local lawmaking power to restrict access to places of public accommodation based on gender identity or expression, a protection the appeals court found is expressly set out in state law. For residents across New York, it clarifies the limits of local authority over civil rights protections.
The Appellate Division ruling on November 4 strikes down the ban that had been blocked by a preliminary injunction since October 2025. Whether the county will pursue further review was not addressed in the available record.
The players
Nassau County
A New York county on Long Island whose legislature enacted the ban on transgender women competing on women's teams at county facilities.
Bruce Blakeman
The Nassau County Executive and Republican nominee for governor who lost to Kathy Hochul in November, and who first signed the executive order barring transgender women's teams from county facilities.
Letitia James
The New York Attorney General whose parallel legal challenge to the ban was ruled in her favor by the appeals court.
New York Civil Liberties Union
The civil liberties organization that brought the lawsuit on behalf of the Long Island Roller Rebels.
The details
The Long Island Roller Rebels, a women's roller derby league that includes transgender players, were represented by the New York Civil Liberties Union in the suit. Blakeman first signed an executive order in February 2024 barring organizations that allow transgender women to compete on women's teams from using more than 100 county facilities, which a state judge struck down in May 2024. The Nassau County Legislature then passed a nearly identical ban.
Timeline
February 2024: Blakeman signs executive order barring transgender women's teams from more than 100 county facilities.
May 2024: A state judge strikes down Blakeman's executive order, finding he overstepped his authority.
October 2025: The Appellate Division grants a preliminary injunction blocking the county's legislative ban.
November 3: Blakeman loses the governor's race to Democratic Gov. Kathy Hochul by about 20 points.
November 4: The appeals court strikes down Nassau County's transgender athlete ban.
Legal Context
The decision applies New York's Human Rights Law and Civil Rights Law, which bar discrimination in public accommodations based on gender identity or expression, to confirm that county ordinances cannot override those state protections. It follows the 2024 state court decision striking down Blakeman's executive order on the grounds that he exceeded his authority.
Transgender athletes in Nassau County, including members of the Long Island Roller Rebels, can now use county athletic facilities again. The ruling confirms that residents' access to public accommodations based on gender identity is protected under New York state law, regardless of county ordinances.
The takeaway
Local governments in New York cannot rely on county law to restrict civil rights protections that state law already guarantees. Residents affected by similar local rules can look to state statutes as the controlling standard.
Further reading
For related court decisions on state versus local authority, see Law coverage on Wisevoter.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Metro Weekly.
Live Poll
Should transgender athletes be allowed to play on women's teams at county facilities?









