State Appeals $11.25 Million Judgment in Stroke Case

New Jersey asks an appeals court to overturn the award to Cheryl Rhines, who was left permanently disabled after a state trooper mistook her stroke symptoms for intoxication.

Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Criminal Justice

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a plain institutional building facade with columned entrance under a pale grey sky, evoking a state legal appeal.
New Jersey asked an appeals court on Tuesday to overturn an $11.25 million judgment awarded to Cheryl Rhines, who was left permanently disabled after a state trooper mistook her stroke symptoms for intoxication. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

New Jersey asked an appeals court to overturn an $11.25 million judgment for Cheryl Rhines, 48, of Jersey City, who was left permanently disabled after a state trooper mistook her stroke symptoms for intoxication. An Appellate Division panel heard arguments on the state's appeal in Trenton.

Why it matters

The case tests whether a state trooper and the state can be held liable for a delay in medical treatment when an officer believes a driver is intoxicated. The outcome could shape how police respond to drivers who show signs of medical emergencies.

The state's appeal of the $11.25 million judgment was filed in October 2025 after Superior Court Judge Thomas Vena denied its request for a new trial in April 2025. The Appellate Division has not yet issued a ruling, and the state argues the trooper acted in good faith and is immune from liability.

The players

New Jersey State Police

The state law enforcement agency whose trooper arrested Rhines and whose barracks in Somerville was where she was taken before medical help arrived.

Trooper Jennifer Albuja

The New Jersey State Police trooper who arrested Rhines and whose conduct is at the center of the liability finding under appeal.

The details

Rhines struck a guardrail on Interstate 78 in Newark on October 17, 2017, while driving to her job in Florham Park. Trooper Jennifer Albuja handcuffed her, searched her car and took her to the New Jersey State Police barracks in Somerville, where emergency medical personnel were eventually called.

Timeline

  1. October 17, 2017: Rhines struck a guardrail on Interstate 78 and Albuja was dispatched.

  2. January 2025: An Essex County jury assessed damages at $19.1 million.

  3. April 2025: Superior Court Judge Thomas Vena denied the state's request for a new trial.

  4. October 2025: The state filed its appeal of the judgment.

  5. November 17, 2026: An Appellate Division panel heard arguments in Trenton.

Legal Context

The state argues Albuja acted in good faith and is immune from liability under New Jersey's Tort Claims Act, which shields public employees from certain damages when they act reasonably. The appeal asks the court to decide how far that protection extends when an officer's assessment of a medical emergency as intoxication results in lasting harm.

Residents who drive in New Jersey may see how the appeal affects how state troopers handle drivers showing signs of medical distress. The ruling could influence whether the state faces financial liability for similar delays in medical care during arrests.

The takeaway

Police encounters with drivers who show unusual symptoms can have lasting consequences when medical needs are misjudged. Readers should note that court rulings on sovereign immunity can take months to resolve and may change how liability is assigned.

Further reading

Explore more coverage in Criminal Justice for related legal developments.

Source note: This article includes information reported by NJ.