Bill Would Let Police Deny Body Cam Requests
New Jersey lawmakers propose blocking commercial use of police body camera footage obtained through public records requests.
Updated on Nov. 11, 2026 in Property Crime

Live Poll
Should police be allowed to deny body camera footage requests made for commercial purposes?
New Jersey lawmakers have proposed a bill that would let law enforcement withhold body camera footage requested for commercial purposes, while exempting news media organizations. Montville's police chief says the department has hired additional staff to handle records requests.
Why it matters
Montville Police Chief Andrew Caggiano says some Open Public Records Act requests target female individuals arrested for driving while intoxicated, with requesters earning ad revenue from clicks on the footage. Supporters say the measure would stop people from profiting off police encounters, while the New Jersey Foundation for Open Government argues it is likely to harm transparency.
The bill is a proposal and has not been enacted, so current law still generally grants body camera footage requests absent an active investigation or other exemption. The number of requests tied to commercial use and the revenue involved have not been quantified in available reporting.
The players
Andrew Caggiano
Montville Police Chief who said the department hired additional staff to handle records requests and redaction, and who described requests targeting female DWI arrestees.
New Jersey Foundation for Open Government
A New Jersey advocacy organization that said the proposal is likely to harm government transparency.
The details
The proposed bill would create an exemption allowing law enforcement to withhold body camera footage requested for commercial use, and would not apply to news media organizations. Caggiano described a pattern in which requesters first seek all DWI arrests in a given month, then file follow-up requests limiting footage to female arrestees.
Timeline
November 11, 2026: News 12 reported on the proposed New Jersey body camera bill.
Legal Context
The proposal would create a carve-out from New Jersey's Open Public Records Act, which currently makes body camera footage broadly available unless tied to an active investigation or otherwise exempt. Whether news media remain exempt from the restriction will shape how the transparency debate under OPRA plays out.
If enacted, the bill would limit residents' ability to obtain police body camera footage for commercial purposes while leaving news organizations unaffected. Residents who rely on OPRA requests for footage would see the scope of available records narrowed for commercial requesters.
The takeaway
The debate centers on balancing government transparency against concerns that public records are being used to profit from people's worst moments. Readers following New Jersey records policy should watch whether the bill advances and how its news media exemption is defined.
Further reading
For related coverage, see more on Property Crime in New Jersey.
Source note: This article includes information reported by News 12 - New Jersey.
Live Poll
Should police be allowed to deny body camera footage requests made for commercial purposes?










