Cup A Joe Has Signed Lease for Third Raleigh Cafe

The local coffee shop will expand its presence on Hillsborough Street into a former seafood restaurant space.

Updated on Sept. 30, 2026 in Openings & Closings

Cup A Joe Has Signed Lease for Third Raleigh Cafe

Live Poll

Is the expansion of long-standing local businesses in your area a positive sign for your community?

Cup A Joe has officially signed a lease for a new location at 3625 Hillsborough St. in Raleigh. The expansion marks the third site for the long-standing coffee business, which has been in operation for 35 years.

Why it matters

The new lease indicates the continued growth and stability of the coffee brand following the death of its founder and the management of its existing locations.

Cup A Joe has maintained operations for 35 years across the Raleigh area. The new site at 3625 Hillsborough St. replaces a commercial space previously occupied by Crafty Crab Seafood, which closed in April 2026.

The players

Cup A Joe

This is a long-standing coffee business that has operated in the Raleigh market since 1991.

Dave Sullivan

He was the original owner of Cup A Joe until his death in December 2023.

The details

The coffee shop will operate out of the space that formerly housed Crafty Crab Seafood. This new site joins the original cafe established in 1991 at 3100 Hillsborough St. and a reopened location at the Mission Valley shopping center.

1991: The original shop on Hillsborough Street opened.
2021: The Mission Valley location closed.
December 2023: Original owner Dave Sullivan died.
August 2025: The Mission Valley location reopened.
April 2026: Crafty Crab Seafood closed at the new site.

Market Landscape

The expansion reflects the historical continuity of independent Raleigh coffee shops along key commercial corridors. This move reinforces the brand's competitive position against newer chains by leveraging its decades-long presence in the local market.

Local coffee drinkers in the Hillsborough Street area can anticipate a new location for the cafe chain. This expansion will likely increase service capacity for residents and students who frequent the corridor.

The takeaway

The addition of a third site suggests that the business successfully navigated the transition of ownership following the founder's passing. Customers can look forward to a new venue maintaining the legacy of a multi-decade local staple.