FirstHealth Sues Blue Cross Over Anesthesia Payment Policy

The Pinehurst health system alleges a policy change ending facility-claim anesthesia reimbursement would cost it an estimated $2.5 million.

Updated on Nov. 21, 2026 in Healthcare

FirstHealth Sues Blue Cross Over Anesthesia Payment Policy

Live Poll

Do you trust health insurers to honor their payment agreements with hospitals?

FirstHealth of the Carolinas filed a complaint against Blue Cross Blue Shield of North Carolina in Durham County over a policy that stops reimbursement for anesthesia services billed as facility claims. The policy change, announced Aug. 31, takes effect Nov. 15.

Why it matters

The change would limit reimbursement to professional claims from outpatient providers, affecting how hospital systems bill for anesthesia care and how much revenue they collect. FirstHealth argues the contract's terms should prevail over the new policy.

FirstHealth estimates it stands to lose $2.5 million because of the policy change, which affects anesthesia services under billing code 0370 that the network agreement does not list as excluded. Blue Cross has not substantively responded to the health system's Oct. 30 letter as of Nov. 13.

The players

Blue Cross Blue Shield of North Carolina

Blue Cross Blue Shield of North Carolina is the state's largest health insurer and a licensee of the national Blue Cross Blue Shield Association.

FirstHealth of the Carolinas

FirstHealth of the Carolinas is a regional health system headquartered in Pinehurst that operates hospitals and outpatient facilities across the central North Carolina region.

The details

FirstHealth alleges the new policy would reimburse only professional claims from outpatient providers, removing payment for anesthesia services, equipment and supplies billed through hospital facility claims. The health system argues the agreement says policies supplement the contract and do not override its terms, and has proposed including CRNA services in professional claims and raising general outpatient reimbursements.

Timeline

  1. Aug. 31, 2025: Blue Cross Blue Shield of North Carolina announces the anesthesia reimbursement policy change.

  2. Oct. 30, 2025: FirstHealth sends a letter invoking the contract's dispute resolution process.

  3. Nov. 13, 2025: FirstHealth files its complaint in Durham County.

  4. Nov. 15, 2025: The policy change is scheduled to take effect.

Market Landscape

The dispute reflects ongoing negotiations between insurers and hospital systems over how anesthesia services are billed, since facility versus professional claim classification directly sets revenue. FirstHealth's challenge centers on whether the network agreement's terms override a unilateral policy change by the insurer.

If the policy takes effect Nov. 15 as scheduled, anesthesia services billed through hospital facility claims will no longer be reimbursed by Blue Cross, which could shift costs toward patients or affect the availability of care at affected facilities. Patients with Blue Cross coverage should watch for any changes to billing at their providers.

The takeaway

Billing classification disputes between insurers and hospitals can carry large financial stakes, and contract language often determines which side prevails. Readers with Blue Cross coverage may want to ask providers how anesthesia services are billed before scheduled procedures.

Further reading

For related coverage, see Healthcare news from across North Carolina.

Source note: This article includes information reported by The Pilot Newspaper.

Live Poll

Do you trust health insurers to honor their payment agreements with hospitals?