FirstHealth Sues Blue Cross NC Over Anesthesia Policy

Pinehurst health system alleges a new reimbursement rule conflicts with a 2021 network participation agreement.

Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in Healthcare

FirstHealth Sues Blue Cross NC Over Anesthesia Policy

Live Poll

Do you trust health insurers to pay providers fairly?

FirstHealth of the Carolinas filed a lawsuit against Blue Cross and Blue Shield of North Carolina on November 13 in Durham Superior Court. The suit challenges an anesthesia reimbursement policy that took effect November 15 and limits reimbursement for anesthesia services to professional claims.

Why it matters

FirstHealth estimates the policy would cost the system about $2.5 million in compensation each year, and the complaint argues it conflicts with a 2021 network participation agreement. The outcome could shape how anesthesia services are reimbursed across facility and professional claims for North Carolina health systems and their insurers.

FirstHealth estimates the policy would cost the system about $2.5 million in compensation each year, according to the complaint filed in Durham Superior Court. The complaint seeks declaratory judgment, injunctive relief, and damages, and the court has not yet ruled on those requests.

The players

FirstHealth of the Carolinas

A health system headquartered in Pinehurst, North Carolina, that is the plaintiff in the lawsuit over anesthesia reimbursement.

Blue Cross and Blue Shield of North Carolina

The state's largest health insurer, which is the defendant in the lawsuit and issued the anesthesia reimbursement policy.

The details

The policy makes anesthesia services from anesthesiologists and CRNAs eligible for reimbursement only on professional claims, and does not allow reimbursement on facility claims. The policy also treats other anesthesia-related services, supplies and equipment as incidental to facility reimbursement, which FirstHealth alleges conflicts with a 2021 network participation agreement. Blue Cross NC states the approach creates more consistent reimbursement and reduces the potential for duplicate payment of the same professional service.

Timeline

  1. November 13, 2026: FirstHealth of the Carolinas filed its lawsuit against Blue Cross NC in Durham Superior Court.

  2. November 15, 2026: The anesthesia reimbursement policy took effect.

Market Landscape

The dispute centers on how insurers and health systems divide anesthesia payments between professional and facility claims, a question that directly shapes negotiated network contracts. A ruling on the 2021 agreement could set a reference point for how similar reimbursement changes are handled in North Carolina's commercial insurance market.

Patients receiving anesthesia care at FirstHealth facilities may see billing changes depending on how claims are processed under the new policy. Blue Cross NC states there will be no impact on members' ability to receive anesthesia coverage.

The takeaway

Check how your health system bills anesthesia services when you receive care, since reimbursement rules between professional and facility claims can affect what you are charged. Ask your provider or insurer to explain any unexpected bills tied to anesthesia.

Further reading

For more on how insurance contracts shape provider payments, see Healthcare coverage across North Carolina.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Becker's Hospital Review | Healthcare News & Analysis.

Live Poll

Do you trust health insurers to pay providers fairly?