Business Court Rules Profit Sharing Not Wages
A North Carolina judge granted partial summary judgment against a former plumbing manager's wage-act claim while keeping his contract and quantum meruit claims alive for trial.
Updated on Nov. 10, 2026 in Public Companies

North Carolina Business Court granted in part a motion for partial summary judgment in a dispute between former Efincia Construction plumbing operations manager Edward Blue and the company's managing member. The court held that the profit-sharing payments at issue were not wages under the North Carolina Wage and Hour Act.
Why it matters
The ruling clarifies that profit-sharing arrangements can fall outside wage-law protections when parties have a consistent course of dealing, which can affect how minority owners and executives are compensated across North Carolina businesses. Breach of contract and quantum meruit claims remain pending, so the underlying compensation dispute is not yet resolved.
The court's ruling rests on more than five years of profit-sharing payments made to Blue Construction Consulting, LLC and reported on IRS Form 1099s as nonemployee compensation. Whether the promised amounts were owed is still unresolved and headed for trial.
The players
North Carolina Business Court
A specialized division of the North Carolina Superior Court that hears complex commercial disputes and issues published opinions shaping state business law.
Efincia Construction
A North Carolina construction company whose managing member and finances are at the center of the compensation dispute.
The details
Blue alleges Efincia Construction and its managing member failed to pay promised profit-sharing and manipulated company finances to reduce his compensation and minority ownership interest. The court granted summary judgment against his Unfair and Deceptive Trade Practices Act claim, finding that a mere intentional breach of contract is insufficient under Chapter 75 absent substantial aggravating circumstances.
Timeline
More than five years before the ruling, profit-sharing payments began flowing to Blue Construction Consulting, LLC at Blue's direction.
The Business Court issued its ruling as 2026 NCBC 70.
Market Landscape
The ruling applies the North Carolina Wage and Hour Act to exclude profit-sharing payments from the statute's definition of wages when the parties consistently treated them that way. It sits alongside the Business Court's Chapter 75 precedent that a mere intentional breach of contract does not support an unfair trade practices claim.
Owners and executives with profit-sharing arrangements should keep written agreements and consistent payment records, since courses of dealing can determine whether payments are treated as wages. Minority owners who believe promised distributions were diverted may need to pursue contract or quantum meruit claims rather than wage-act claims.
The takeaway
Written profit-sharing terms and a clear record of how payments are classified can prevent costly disputes over whether compensation is wages or contract income. Parties relying on a consistent course of dealing should document it, because courts will look to that history when classifying payments.
Further reading
For more on how privately held and public firms structure executive compensation, see Public Companies.
Source note: This article includes information reported by North Carolina Lawyers Weekly.










