Carroll Slips to No. 14 in NAIA Football Poll

The Fighting Saints dropped two spots after their first loss since September, a 48-41 defeat at College of Idaho.

Updated on Nov. 11, 2026 in Football

Expressive editorial sports illustration of a red and gold jersey football player carrying the ball past a blue and white defender across an open field.
Carroll fell two spots to No. 14 in the NAIA football poll after a 48-41 loss at No. 1 College of Idaho, its first defeat since September. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Carroll football team slipped two spots to No. 14 in the penultimate 2026 STADIONIC NAIA Football National Selection Committee Poll, released Nov. 10. The Fighting Saints are 7-2 overall and 4-1 in Frontier-West play after losing 48-41 on the road to College of Idaho.

Why it matters

Carroll was the only team to stay within one score of College of Idaho's offense and the only team to score more than 28 points against it. The Fighting Saints remain in contention for a return to the NAIA Football Championship Series, with a win at Eastern Oregon in their regular-season finale making playoff football in Helena highly probable.

Carroll's 48-41 loss to College of Idaho was its first game since September, and it was the only team to hold College of Idaho within one score and to exceed 28 points against it. The NAIA's penultimate poll does not address how Carroll's ranking will move after its final regular-season game.

The players

Carroll College Fighting Saints

Carroll College is a private college in Helena, Montana, whose football program competes in the NAIA's Frontier Conference.

College of Idaho

The College of Idaho is a private liberal arts college in Caldwell, Idaho, which is ranked No. 1 in the NAIA football poll.

NAIA

The National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics is a U.S. governing body for small college athletics that administers the national football poll and championship series.

The details

Carroll lost 48-41 on the road to College of Idaho, the No. 1 team in the poll. The result dropped the Fighting Saints two spots, with the poll released by the NAIA from Kansas City, Mo. Carroll concludes its regular season at Eastern Oregon.

Timeline

  1. Nov. 10, 2026: NAIA releases the penultimate 2026 STADIONIC NAIA Football National Selection Committee Poll.

  2. September 2026: Carroll plays its last game before the College of Idaho loss.

  3. Next weekend: Potential playoff football returns to Helena if Carroll wins at Eastern Oregon.

Season Trajectory

The NAIA's penultimate poll of the 2026 season sets the stage for playoff selection, and Carroll's two-spot drop comes after its first loss since September. Carroll remains in contention for the NAIA Football Championship Series, while Frontier Conference teams College of Idaho and Montana Tech hold the top positions among ranked conference programs.

A win at Eastern Oregon would keep Carroll in playoff contention and bring postseason football back to Helena the following weekend. A loss would leave the Fighting Saints' playoff path uncertain, and the final poll ranking would reflect that outcome.

The takeaway

Carroll's 7-2 record and close loss to the nation's top-ranked team show a program still positioned for a postseason run. Its final regular-season game at Eastern Oregon will decide whether playoff football returns to Helena.

What happens next

Carroll finishes its regular season at Eastern Oregon, and a win would make a return to playoff football in Helena highly probable. The NAIA's final 2026 football poll will follow that result.

Further reading

For more context on the team's season, see Football coverage on Wisevoter.