Judge Blocks Montana Sex Definition Law

A Missoula County judge has paused enforcement of Senate Bill 437 while a lawsuit challenging the measure proceeds.

Updated on Nov. 21, 2026 in Law

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a plain stone civic building against a distant mountain ridge, evoking the legal pause on a Montana state law.
Montana Judge Leslie Halligan paused enforcement of Senate Bill 437, a 2025 state law defining sex by reproductive anatomy, while a lawsuit challenging it proceeds. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should Montana state law define sex as only male or female?

Missoula County District Court Judge Leslie Halligan granted a preliminary injunction against Senate Bill 437, a 2025 Montana Legislature measure that defines "male" and "female" based on reproductive anatomy. The Montana Attorney General's office said the state will appeal the decision.

Why it matters

The ruling halts enforcement of a state law that equates "gender" with "sex" and excludes gender identity and gender expression, affecting how Montana defines sex across state policy. The lawsuit is the third legal challenge against Senate Bill 437 and a 2023 measure, which two separate judges, including Halligan, previously blocked.

Halligan granted the injunction on Monday, and the Montana Attorney General's office says it will appeal. The injunction remains in effect while the lawsuit proceeds in court.

The players

Leslie Halligan

Missoula County District Court judge who granted the preliminary injunction and had previously blocked the 2023 measure.

Greg Gianforte

Governor of Montana who signed Senate Bill 437 into law in March 2026.

Carl Glimm

Republican state senator from Kila who sponsored both Senate Bill 437 and the 2023 measure.

Montana Department of Justice

State agency whose Attorney General's office announced it will appeal the injunction.

The details

Helena-based Upper Seven Law filed the lawsuit in April on behalf of a group of intersex and transgender individuals. Halligan concluded the plaintiffs were likely to succeed on claims that the law violates constitutional rights to privacy and equal protection. Sen. Carl Glimm, R-Kila, sponsored both bills and said he modified the language to correct for the court's findings on the 2023 measure.

Timeline

  1. 2023: Legislature passes an earlier measure defining sex, later blocked by two judges.

  2. 2025: Legislature passes Senate Bill 437 with Republican-only support.

  3. March 2026: Gov. Greg Gianforte signs Senate Bill 437 into law after holding it for nearly a year.

  4. April 2026: Upper Seven Law files the lawsuit challenging the measure.

  5. Monday (week of Nov. 16, 2026): Halligan grants the preliminary injunction.

Legal Context

Senate Bill 437 follows the 2023 Montana measure that two judges already blocked, and the new law was rewritten to address the courts' earlier findings. The case tests whether that revised approach can withstand the constitutional privacy and equal protection claims that defeated its predecessor.

While the injunction remains in place, Senate Bill 437 cannot be enforced in Montana. The outcome of the state's appeal will determine whether its sex definitions take effect for residents and state agencies.

The takeaway

Court rulings on state definitions of sex often hinge on constitutional privacy and equal protection claims, and the appeal in this case will show whether Montana's revised law can withstand them.

Further reading

Explore more Law coverage tied to this Montana ruling on sex definitions.

Source note: This article includes information reported by The Independent Record.

Live Poll

Should Montana state law define sex as only male or female?