Appeals Court Upholds Ruling in Uninsured Motorist Coverage Suit
A Missouri appeals court affirmed summary judgment for an insurance agent and agency in a negligent failure-to-procure case.
Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Insurance

Live Poll
Do you trust your insurance agent to get the coverage you request?
The Missouri Court of Appeals, Southern District, affirmed summary judgment for a Missouri insurance agent and agency on a negligent failure-to-procure claim, ruling on October 30, 2025. The policyholder alleged he had requested $100,000 in uninsured motorist coverage, but the court found his discovery responses did not establish a request for fully stackable coverage.
Why it matters
The ruling reinforces that an insurance agent's liability for failing to procure coverage depends on the specific requests a policyholder can document. Policyholders who seek stacked or layered uninsured motorist coverage across multiple vehicles may need written records of the exact amounts and policies requested.
The court relied on the policyholder's own discovery responses admitting three separate requests on three dates for three coverage amounts across three policies. The reduced $25,000 per-person payouts under other policies were tied to an endorsement that applied because the insured was not occupying those vehicles at the time of the accident.
The players
State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company
State Farm is one of the largest auto insurers in the United States, offering a wide range of personal lines and coverage products. Its endorsements and uninsured motorist terms have been the subject of several coverage disputes in state courts.
The details
A Missouri policyholder was struck by an uninsured driver in July 2018 while occupying his 2011 Toyota Tacoma. He sued his insurer for breach of contract and vexatious refusal to pay, and the trial court granted summary judgment to the insurer. He then sued his agent and agency for negligent failure to procure insurance, and the trial court granted summary judgment to them as well before the appeal was decided.
Timeline
April 2013: The policyholder requested $100,000 in uninsured motorist coverage for his 2011 Toyota Tacoma.
November 2016: The insurer issued endorsement 6128CP, which reduced benefits for vehicles not occupied at the time of an accident.
July 2018: The policyholder was involved in an accident with an uninsured vehicle while occupying the 2011 Tacoma.
October 30, 2025: The Missouri Court of Appeals, Southern District, affirmed summary judgment for the agent and agency.
Market Landscape
The decision follows Missouri's long-standing framework for uninsured motorist coverage under Revised Statutes section 379.203, which shapes how carriers and agents document coverage offers. It clarifies that agent liability for failure to procure turns on the specific, provable requests a policyholder made rather than on general expectations of stacked coverage.
Missouri drivers who want stacked uninsured motorist coverage should ask their agent to document each coverage amount and policy in writing. Reviewing endorsements that limit benefits for vehicles not occupied during an accident can prevent unexpected reductions in payouts.
The takeaway
Ask for written confirmation of every coverage amount you request, on every vehicle and policy, and keep copies. Review endorsements before an accident so you know when benefits may be reduced.
Further reading
For related coverage rules, see Insurance news from across Missouri.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Missouri Lawyers Media.
Live Poll
Do you trust your insurance agent to get the coverage you request?










