Court Denies Equipment Firm's Bid in Hammer Dispute

A Michigan court declined to rule in favor of an equipment seller in a contract and conversion case involving a construction company.

Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Industry

Photograph of a single hydraulic hammer attachment resting on bare earth at the edge of a construction lot under flat overcast Midwestern sky.
A Michigan court declined to rule for equipment seller CJ Equipment, Inc. in its lawsuit against a construction company over an SJ1250 hydraulic hammer. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

A Michigan court denied a motion for summary disposition filed by CJ Equipment, Inc., which sells and leases heavy construction equipment, in its lawsuit against a Michigan construction company. The dispute centers on an SJ1250 hydraulic hammer, and the court found that genuine factual questions remain on the breach of contract and conversion claims.

Why it matters

The ruling means the contract and conversion claims will proceed to further proceedings rather than being resolved on the existing record. It shows how disputes over equipment rental terms and possession can turn on factual questions that courts must leave for resolution.

The court's ruling concerns a single SJ1250 hydraulic hammer, and Count II was dismissed on January 9, 2026, while the breach of contract and conversion counts remain active. The court did not resolve whether the rental terms were agreed or whether the hammer was wrongfully withheld.

The players

CJ Equipment, Inc.

A company that sells and leases heavy construction equipment and brought the motion seeking summary disposition in the case.

The details

CJ Equipment, Inc. asked the court to rule in its favor without a trial, arguing the record supported its claims. The court viewed the evidence in the light most favorable to the defendants and declined to weigh credibility or conflicting evidence, while noting that nonpayment itself is not materially disputed.

Timeline

  1. January 9, 2026: Unjust enrichment claim (Count II) dismissed.

Market Landscape

The ruling applies the summary disposition standard under MCR 2.116(C)(10) to a dispute over heavy equipment rental in Michigan's construction sector. It reflects how equipment lessors in this market must often prove contract terms and possession through a full factual record rather than through early motions.

Contractors and equipment lessors in Michigan should document rental terms in writing, since disputes over unwritten agreements and equipment possession can proceed to costly litigation. The case shows that unresolved factual questions can keep a claim alive well past the initial filing stage.

The takeaway

Written rental agreements and clear records of equipment delivery and return can prevent disputes like this one from reaching court. Businesses that lease or rent heavy equipment should treat documentation as a core part of their contracts.

Further reading

For more context on equipment disputes in the construction trade, explore Construction coverage on Wisevoter.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Michigan Lawyers Weekly.