Judge Dismisses Charges Against Therron Spencer

Baltimore prosecutors' case collapsed after several witnesses failed to appear on time for testimony.

Updated on Nov. 9, 2026 in Violence

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a stone courthouse facade with columns and a motionless flag across an empty plaza, in deep red, cream, and slate grey.
Baltimore Circuit Judge Lynn S. Mays dismissed all charges against Therron Spencer after several witnesses failed to appear for testimony in a March shooting case. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Baltimore City Circuit Court Judge Lynn S. Mays dismissed all charges against 29-year-old Therron Spencer, who had faced four counts of attempted first-degree murder, four counts of first-degree assault, and multiple firearm charges. The dismissal followed a March shooting that left a 34-year-old victim in critical condition.

Why it matters

The ruling shows how a witness's absence can end a prosecution before it reaches a verdict, even in a serious violent-crime case. For Baltimore residents, it underscores the importance of witness availability in cases involving shootings on the city's streets.

All charges against Therron Spencer, aged 29, were dismissed by Judge Lynn S. Mays on November 9, 2026, after the court declined to let a late detective testify. Prosecutors have not yet publicly stated whether they will refile or appeal.

The players

Lynn S. Mays

Lynn S. Mays is a judge of the Baltimore City Circuit Court who presided over the case and ruled to dismiss the charges.

John Deros

John Deros is a defense attorney who argued the state needed to prove it had the right person and moved for dismissal.

Baltimore City Police Department

The Baltimore City Police Department is the local agency whose detectives investigated the shooting and testified in the case.

The details

The shooting occurred in March on the 3100 block of Oakford Avenue during a cookout, where a verbal altercation allegedly escalated and the shooting left a 34-year-old victim critical after he stepped between the antagonists. Defense attorney John Deros argued the state had to prove it had the right person, and the defense moved for dismissal after witnesses failed to appear and the case was unreasonably delayed.

Timeline

  1. March: Shooting on the 3100 block of Oakford Avenue left a 34-year-old victim in critical condition.

  2. October: Brandon Therron Spencer, aged 49, was acquitted of eight charges at trial.

  3. November 9, 2026: Judge Lynn S. Mays dismissed all charges against Therron Spencer.

Legal Context

Dismissals driven by missing witnesses and delay reflect how Maryland circuit courts enforce procedural timelines in violent-crime prosecutions. The outcome mirrors the pattern of cases in Baltimore where evidentiary gaps, rather than a jury finding, determine whether charges proceed.

Residents near the Oakford Avenue and Park Heights Avenue areas may see the case resolved without a trial verdict, which affects community confidence in local prosecutions. Businesses and neighbors in Baltimore should note that charges can be dismissed when key witnesses are unavailable.

The takeaway

Timely witness availability is essential to prosecuting violent crime, and cases can collapse when it is not secured. Baltimore residents who witness violence should be prepared to appear when subpoenaed so that charges are not lost to delay.

Further reading

For related coverage, see Violence in the Baltimore crime section.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Baltimore Witness.