NTSB Faults Pilots in Baltimore Port Ship Collision

A federal report says harbor pilots did not adequately adjust docking plans as extreme winds struck the Morning Menad at Dundalk Marine Terminal.

Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Industry

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a steel cargo ship hull turned sideways against a gray harbor beside a concrete quay, evoking a wind-driven docking mishap.
Federal investigators found harbor pilots kept their original docking plan as extreme winds pushed the 577-foot Morning Menad into a Baltimore terminal in December 2024. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you expect shipping disruptions to raise what you pay for goods?

On December 5, 2024, the 577-foot cargo ship Morning Menad, carrying 4,212 automobiles, struck the Dundalk Marine Terminal in Baltimore during gusts reaching 50 knots, or 58 mph. The collision damaged a concrete wall, bollards, signs and a video surveillance system.

Why it matters

The National Transportation Safety Board's findings point to decision-making under changing weather as a factor in the incident, which bears on how Port of Baltimore pilots and vessels handle berthing in high winds. Baltimore is a major vehicle-handling port, so the findings matter to the port's operations and the region's freight activity.

The collision caused about $1.2 million in damage to terminal infrastructure and about $200,000 in vessel repairs, with the ship carrying 4,212 automobiles at the time. The final cost split between the parties has not been set, as the Maryland Port Administration continues talks on an agreed repair plan.

The players

Wilhelmsen Ship Management

Wilhelmsen Ship Management is the ship management company associated with the Morning Menad vessel involved in the incident.

Maryland Port Administration

The Maryland Port Administration is the state agency that operates the Port of Baltimore and is leading discussions on the terminal repair plan.

National Transportation Safety Board

The National Transportation Safety Board is the federal agency that investigates transportation accidents and issued the report on the collision.

The details

The ship had to turn 150 degrees counterclockwise and reverse into its berth, but it was blown sideways during the turn. Crew members deployed an anchor, but the vessel bumped into the concrete and grounded. Two tugboats were called, and the ship was freed about 90 minutes later, then moored elsewhere. The NTSB found the pilots kept the original docking plan even after conditions changed, a pattern it linked to continuation bias.

Timeline

  1. December 5, 2024: The Morning Menad struck the Dundalk Marine Terminal in high winds.

  2. About 90 minutes after grounding: The ship was freed by four tugboats and moored elsewhere.

  3. Nearly two years later: The terminal remained unrepaired as of the report.

  4. Monday, before publication: The Maryland Port Administration issued a statement on repair discussions.

Market Landscape

The incident came eight months after the Francis Scott Key Bridge collapse, which disrupted shipping through the Port of Baltimore. Baltimore ranks No. 2 nationally for automobile handling, and the port handles roughly 2,000 cargo ships annually, so berthing reliability matters to its competitive position against other East Coast ports.

Shoppers and businesses that depend on imported vehicles and freight moving through Baltimore may see delays or cost changes if berth repairs take longer to complete. The final repair and cost plan could affect how quickly the affected terminal returns to full capacity.

The takeaway

The NTSB finding underscores that port operators need to reassess berthing plans as wind conditions change, rather than holding to the original schedule. Port users and logistics planners can factor weather-related delay risk into shipment timing at Baltimore terminals.

Further reading

For more on how port logistics shape regional freight, explore Transportation coverage on Baltimore's shipping sector.

Source note: This article includes information reported by The Baltimore Banner.

Live Poll

Do you expect shipping disruptions to raise what you pay for goods?