Professor Sues Navy Over End of Civilian Tenure

A proposed class action in Maryland federal court challenges the Naval Academy's policy ending tenure review for civilian faculty.

Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Military

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a weathered stone academic hall facade with a bare flagpole under an overcast sky.
An anonymous Naval Academy professor sued the Navy in Maryland federal court Tuesday, challenging its end of tenure review for civilian faculty. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should the federal government be able to end tenure for its civilian professors?

An anonymous tenure-track professor has filed a proposed class-action lawsuit in Maryland U.S. District Court challenging the Navy's policy ending tenure review for civilian Naval Academy professors. The Navy enacted the policy earlier in November 2026, following a September 2026 memo from Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth.

Why it matters

The policy affects the Naval Academy's civilian faculty, and the lawsuit asks the court to preserve the tenure-review process for current tenure-track professors. Hegseth's memo argues that tenure contributes to academic stagnation and curriculum drift from the warfighting mission.

The lawsuit brings two counts under the Administrative Procedure Act against the Navy, its secretary, and the Naval Academy's provost and superintendent. The plaintiff is represented by Jason Ehrenberg of Holon Law Partners in Bethesda, and no ruling has been issued.

The players

U.S. Navy

The U.S. Navy is the naval warfare service branch of the United States armed forces, and it is a named defendant in the lawsuit over its civilian tenure policy.

U.S. Naval Academy

The U.S. Naval Academy is a federal service academy in Annapolis, Maryland, that trains officers for the Navy and Marine Corps and whose civilian faculty tenure policy is challenged.

Pete Hegseth

Pete Hegseth is the U.S. Secretary of Defense, who issued the September 2026 memo directing military academies to stop granting tenure to civilian faculty.

The details

The proposed class includes professors who held tenure-track positions as of Sept. 29, 2026, and the policy does not end tenure for civilians who already have it or apply to uniformed professors. The plaintiff, who was scheduled for tenure review in spring 2027, asks for a tenure opportunity and an injunction preserving the review process.

Timeline

  1. September 2026: Hegseth issues memo directing military academies to stop granting civilian tenure.

  2. Sept. 29, 2026: Class membership cutoff date tied to the Hegseth memo.

  3. Earlier in November 2026: Navy enacts policy ending the civilian tenure-review process.

  4. Monday, November 2026: Proposed class-action lawsuit filed in Maryland U.S. District Court.

  5. Spring 2027: Plaintiff's scheduled tenure review.

Roadmap

The Navy's policy follows Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth's September 2026 memo, which directed military academies to stop granting tenure to civilian faculty. The lawsuit tests whether that directive can be applied under the Administrative Procedure Act to professors already in the tenure-track pipeline.

Civilian tenure-track professors at the Naval Academy face the loss of the tenure-review process, which affects job security for current faculty. The lawsuit's outcome will determine whether the tenure-review process continues for those professors.

The takeaway

The case shows how a federal personnel policy on academic tenure can be contested in court by affected faculty. Readers following defense policy can track the ruling as it develops.

Further reading

Explore more coverage in the Military section for context on defense policy and military academies.

Live Poll

Should the federal government be able to end tenure for its civilian professors?