Court Rules Gym Waiver Cannot Bar Child Injury Claim

The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court found a liability waiver unenforceable against a West Boylston children's gymnastics center.

Updated on Nov. 12, 2026 in Gymnastics

Screen-print poster illustration of a single low wooden balance beam above a padded mat in a bare gymnasium, in mustard, teal, cream, and rust, evoking a gym-safety legal ruling.
The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court ruled that a liability waiver cannot bar a negligence claim against a West Boylston children's gymnastics center after a 5-year-old fell during class. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

The Supreme Judicial Court ruled that a liability waiver does not bar a negligence claim against a West Boylston children's gymnastics center after a 5-year-old girl fell from a piece of equipment during a class. The court found the center is a health club under state law, making the waiver unenforceable.

Why it matters

The decision applies Massachusetts General Laws chapter 93, section 80, which prohibits health club contracts from containing provisions where a buyer agrees not to assert claims against the seller arising from activities at the club. Families who sign such waivers at similar facilities in Massachusetts may still be able to pursue negligence claims.

The 16-page decision, Cross v. BeFree Enterprises, LLC (Lawyers Weekly No. 10-126-26), addresses a 5-year-old plaintiff and a center whose classes serve children up to age twelve. The filing does not address the injury's severity or the damages sought.

The players

Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts

The Supreme Judicial Court is the highest appellate court in Massachusetts, responsible for final interpretation of state law.

The details

The plaintiff's father signed a liability waiver before the girl took part in a gymnastics class at the West Boylston center, which includes a padded room with gymnastics equipment and employs coaches. A coach was present when she fell. The court concluded the waiver was part of a contract for health club services and therefore unenforceable under state law.

Timeline

  1. Ruling published November 12, 2026 by the Supreme Judicial Court.

Season Trajectory

The ruling applies Massachusetts General Laws chapter 93, section 80, which bars health club contracts from waiving claims against the seller, to a children's gymnastics center. It extends the statute's reach to youth athletic facilities that sell recurring classes.

Parents who sign waivers at gymnastics or youth fitness classes in Massachusetts may have stronger grounds to pursue negligence claims than the waiver language suggests. Facilities that sell recurring classes may need to revisit their enrollment paperwork.

The takeaway

Liability waivers do not automatically shield businesses from negligence claims in Massachusetts, particularly where state health club law applies. Families reviewing enrollment paperwork should note that such provisions may be unenforceable.

Further reading

Explore more gymnastics coverage for Massachusetts readers.