Court Rejects Anti-SLAPP Bid in Massachusetts Prosthetics Dispute

A Massachusetts federal court denied a special anti-SLAPP motion but dismissed two fraud-related counterclaims in a non-competition dispute between two prosthetics businesses.

Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Law

Court Rejects Anti-SLAPP Bid in Massachusetts Prosthetics Dispute

A federal court in Massachusetts denied a special anti-SLAPP motion to dismiss counterclaims filed by a prosthetics lab in a dispute over an alleged breach of a non-competition agreement. The court granted a separate Rule 12(b)(6) motion and dismissed the fraudulent and negligent misrepresentation counterclaims.

Why it matters

The ruling applies the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court's 2024 Bristol Asphalt decision, which holds that prelitigation demand letters do not count as petitioning activity under the state's anti-SLAPP statute. It shows how courts separate protected petitioning from ordinary commercial claims when businesses sue over contract terms.

The court denied the special anti-SLAPP motion and granted the Rule 12(b)(6) motion, leaving the case in active civil litigation. The remaining chapter 93A counterclaim and the underlying breach-of-non-competition claim have not been resolved in the extraction.

The players

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court is the state's highest court, and its 2024 Bristol Asphalt decision shapes how lower courts apply the state's anti-SLAPP statute.

The details

The plaintiff, a Massachusetts orthotics and prosthetics practice, sued a Massachusetts prosthetics lab and an individual over an alleged breach of a non-competition agreement tied to a 2018 agreement. The defendants countered with claims of fraudulent misrepresentation, negligent misrepresentation, and violation of Massachusetts General Laws chapter 93A, prompting the plaintiff to seek dismissal under both the state anti-SLAPP statute and federal Rule 12(b)(6).

Timeline

  1. 2018: The 2018 Agreement at the center of the dispute is signed.

  2. 2024: The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court decides Bristol Asphalt Co. v. Rochester Bituminous Products, Inc., which the court relies on.

  3. November 10, 2026: The court denies the anti-SLAPP motion and dismisses the fraud-related counterclaims.

Legal Context

The ruling applies Bristol Asphalt Co. v. Rochester Bituminous Products, Inc., 493 Mass. 539 (2024), which holds that prelitigation demand letters are not petitioning activity under Massachusetts' anti-SLAPP statute. Massachusetts courts continue to sort mixed petitioning and non-petitioning claims case by case under that framework.

Businesses in Massachusetts that send demand letters before filing suit may find those letters outside the anti-SLAPP statute's protection, which affects how they can respond to a dispute. Companies that include non-competition terms in agreements should expect those terms to be litigated on their contract language and any alleged misrepresentations.

The takeaway

Demand letters sent before a lawsuit may not receive anti-SLAPP protection in Massachusetts, so parties should weigh that risk before responding to a business dispute. Misrepresentation counterclaims also need specific allegations of reasonable reliance to survive a motion to dismiss.

Further reading

For related rulings on how state courts handle these claims, see Law coverage on Wisevoter.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly.