Sour Patch Kids Top Massachusetts Halloween Candy Rankings
The sour treat has unseated Butterfinger as the state favorite following a shift in consumer preference.
Updated on Oct. 21, 2026 in Desserts
Live Poll
Are you changing what you buy for holidays because of higher prices?
Sour Patch Kids has become the most popular Halloween candy in Massachusetts for 2026. This change displaces Butterfinger, which held the top spot in the state in 2024.
Why it matters
Rising chocolate prices have led consumers to pivot toward fruity and sour alternatives. This transition is reflected in twelve states reporting a new favorite Halloween candy this year.
Sour Patch Kids now ranks first in 10 states, while Butterfinger dropped in 4 state rankings compared to 2024. Nationally, candy spending is projected to reach $4.1 billion out of a total $13.5 billion in Halloween spending.
The players
CandyStore.com
This is an online retailer that publishes annual data analysis on regional and national candy preferences.
Sour Patch Kids
This is a brand of sour-then-sweet candy that has gained significant market share as a preferred Halloween treat.
Butterfinger
This is a crispety-crunchety peanut-buttery candy bar that previously dominated popularity rankings in several states.
The details
Data from CandyStore.com, which analyzed 19 years of sales figures, shows that seven states have shifted from chocolate-based favorites to non-chocolate options. While Sour Patch Kids leads in Massachusetts, M&M's remains the most popular choice by sales volume across the United States.
Timeline
2024 was the year Butterfinger held the top ranking for Massachusetts.
2026 is the current year for the Halloween candy sales rankings.
Culture Shift
This transition in state preferences reflects a broader movement where inflationary pressure on legacy chocolate brands drives consumers toward cheaper, non-chocolate alternatives. It illustrates a departure from long-standing loyalty toward traditional candy bars as households re-evaluate seasonal budgets.
Residents may find different candy assortments in local stores this year as retailers adjust inventory to meet shifting state preferences. The rise in candy prices suggests that shoppers might see smaller bags or higher costs for their preferred treats compared to previous seasons.
The takeaway
Consumers are increasingly sensitive to price fluctuations, opting for sour or fruity candies over chocolate during the holiday season. Shoppers should check local retailer stocks early to avoid missing out on the newly favored treats in their area.
Further reading
Explore more trends in the industry by visiting the Desserts section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Masslive.
Live Poll
Are you changing what you buy for holidays because of higher prices?
