Ex-Library Board Member Sues Gary School District
Robert L. Buggs Sr. alleges due process violations and defamation after being removed from the Gary Public Library Board at a 2025 hearing.
Updated on Nov. 12, 2026 in Administration

Live Poll
Do you trust your local school board to follow fair process?
Former Gary Public Library Board member Robert L. Buggs Sr. filed a civil lawsuit against Gary Community School Corp. on November 4, alleging deprivation of procedural due process, defamation per se, and intentional infliction of emotional distress. The suit stems from his removal at a public hearing on April 10, 2025.
Why it matters
The lawsuit raises questions about how removal decisions for appointed board members are made and documented in Gary. Residents interested in library governance and school district accountability may find the case's claims about notice and public process relevant.
The complaint alleges Buggs was not told the reasons for his removal and that the board refused written complaints, while the district's public records response came about six months after his April 28 request. Whether the board will contest these allegations in court has not been addressed.
The players
Gary Community School Corp.
The public school district that serves Gary, Indiana, and is named as the defendant in the lawsuit over the removal of Buggs.
Robert L. Buggs Sr.
A former member of the Gary Public Library Board who filed suit after being removed from his post.
The details
Buggs says he was removed at the April 10 hearing without being informed of the cause, and that witness Michael Pirtle was barred from speaking unless he signed in as a general public commenter. The lawsuit also alleges a board member who arrived at the end of the hearing voted for removal.
Timeline
April 10, 2025: School board holds public hearing and removes Buggs.
April 28, 2025: Buggs submits public records requests.
October 31, 2025: School district responds to the records requests.
November 4: Buggs files the civil lawsuit.
Legal Context
This suit follows Buggs' earlier case against Paige McNulty and Gary Community School Corp., which the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals rejected on appeal on September 17. The new complaint extends a continuing dispute between Buggs and the district over his removal from public board service.
Residents who use Gary Public Library or follow school board decisions may see how removal and appointment procedures are handled. The case's outcome could influence how public hearings on board membership are conducted in the city.
The takeaway
Public hearings on appointed board members are meant to give notice and a chance to respond, and the outcome of this suit may clarify what those protections require. Readers who attend or follow such hearings can ask for written reasons and records.
Further reading
For related coverage, see Administration in Gary.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Nwitimes.
Live Poll
Do you trust your local school board to follow fair process?










